<@ULVA73B9P> there is a bit of help i need in one ...
# marvin-ai
k
@Marvin there is a bit of help i need in one of my data aggregation pipeline, i am using self hosted prefect-dbt for my data aggregation database is postgres currently my setup is on the ec2 instance , i am using the daemon processes to run my local work pool and prefect server i am not using the default sql lite db but i am using the postgres instance to save the logs for each store i have separate deployment, i have created deployments in the prefect.yaml like this # Welcome to your prefect.yaml file! You can use this file for storing and managing # configuration for deploying your flows. We recommend committing this file to source # control along with your flow code. # Generic metadata about this project name: dbt prefect-version: 3.4.15 # build section allows you to manage and build docker images build: null # push section allows you to manage if and how this project is uploaded to remote locations push: null # pull section allows you to provide instructions for cloning this project in remote locations pull: - prefect.deployments.steps.git_clone: repository: https://github.com/xyzorg/abcrepo.git branch: dev access_token: '{{ prefect.blocks.secret.dbt-git-repo-token}}' # the deployments section allows you to provide configuration for deploying flows deployments: - name: "Clickstream Aggregation' version: null tags: ['clickstream-aggregation', 'prod'] concurrency_limit: limit: 1 collision_strategy: CANCEL_NEW description: |- Args: database: Database name models: Specific models to run full_refresh: Whether to do full refresh (default: false) store_timezone_offset_minutes: Timezone offset (default: "330") entrypoint: flows/clickstream/clickstream.py:clickstream_dbt_run parameters: database: "2427b5-28" full_refresh: false store_timezone_offset_minutes: "330" models: tag:clickstream is_complete_clickstream_run: true work_pool: name: local-work-pool work_queue_name: null job_variables: {} schedules: - interval: 1800.0 slug: default-aggregation-schedule anchor_date: '2025-09-09T073000.000000+00:00' timezone: UTC active: false - cron: "0 0 * * 0" # Every Sunday at 00:00 UTC timezone: "UTC" slug: daily-aggregation-schedule active: false parameters: run_daily: true currently setup is not automated, the main problem i am facing is that X users integrates with the service, now post integration ideally what should happen is that it should create a deployment in some manner and should be deployed on the instance and based on the first run the tables should be created for the same there is currenly no ci/cd for the same , i want to automate this setup such that when x service calls my this setup it should have some prefect api which creates deployment sort of thing, and run based on the same help me constrcut the architecture for this and help me set this up set by step
m
thought for 638.6 seconds
Thanks for the detailed context — that helps a lot. Here’s a robust, automation-first architecture for your use case (Prefect 3.4.15, self-hosted, Postgres, process worker) that will let “service X” provision a new store by creating a deployment and kicking off an initial run to create tables. High-level architecture - Keep one reusable, parameterized dbt flow (clickstream_dbt_run). - For each new store, programmatically create a new deployment from that flow with store-specific defaults. - Enforce per-deployment concurrency (limit=1, CANCEL_NEW) to avoid overlapping runs for the same store. - After creating the deployment, trigger a “bootstrap” run that sets
full_refresh=true
(or similar) to create/refresh tables. - Back the deployment from source (your Git repo) so the worker always pulls latest code. - Expose an internal Provisioning API (FastAPI or similar) that service X calls; it uses Prefect’s Python API to create/update deployments and trigger the first run. Why this works well - It’s fully API-driven (no manual
prefect deploy
runs needed). - It scales to many stores (1 deployment per store). - It respects your current infra (EC2, Prefect Server w/ Postgres, process worker). - It preserves your dbt conventions and lets you keep using a single flow with parameters. Step-by-step setup 0) Prereqs (confirm these once) - Prefect Server configured to use Postgres (already done) - One work pool for your process worker, e.g.
local-work-pool
- Create if needed:
Copy code
prefect work-pool create local-work-pool --type process
- A worker running against that pool on your EC2 instance:
Copy code
prefect worker start -p local-work-pool
- Secret block for your Git access token (the same one you reference in prefect.yaml): - In Python once:
Copy code
from prefect.blocks.system import Secret
    Secret(value="<YOUR_GIT_TOKEN>").save("dbt-git-repo-token", overwrite=True)
- Or create it in the UI. 1) Make sure your dbt flow is parameterized Your flow already takes params like
database
,
models
,
full_refresh
,
store_timezone_offset_minutes
, etc. Perfect. Keep that entrypoint: -
flows/clickstream/clickstream.py:clickstream_dbt_run
2) Provisioning service (API) to create deployments per store Deploy this (FastAPI example) alongside your EC2 services. This endpoint: - Creates/updates a deployment for a given store - Enforces per-deployment concurrency (limit=1, CANCEL_NEW) - Triggers a bootstrap run with
full_refresh=True
on first provision ``` from fastapi import FastAPI, HTTPException from pydantic import BaseModel from typing import Optional from prefect.client.orchestration import get_client from prefect.runner.storage import GitRepository from prefect.blocks.system import Secret from prefect import flow from prefect.client.schemas.objects import ConcurrencyLimitConfig, ConcurrencyLimitStrategy # IMPORTANT: Ensure ENV is set where this service runs: # - PREFECT_API_URL=http//&lt;your prefect server host&gt;4200/api # If you use Prefect Cloud, also set PREFECT_API_KEY. app = FastAPI(title="Prefect Provisioning API") class ProvisionRequest(BaseModel): store_id: str database: str models: Optional[str] = None # e.g., "tag:clickstream" branch: Optional[str] = "dev" store_timezone_offset_minutes: Optional[str] = "330" is_complete_clickstream_run: Optional[bool] = True default_full_refresh: Optional[bool] = False repo_url: str = "https://github.com/xyzorg/abcrepo.git" def _build_flow_from_source(repo_url: str, branch: str): # Use a GitRepository with Secret block for private repo access git_token = Secret.load("dbt-git-repo-token") # created earlier return flow.from_source( source=GitRepository( url=repo_url, branch=branch, credentials={"access_token": git_token} ), entrypoint="flows/clickstream/clickstream.py:clickstream_dbt_run", ) @app.post("/provision-store")
async def provision_store(req: ProvisionRequest): # 1) Reference the flow from source (repo + entrypoint) try: store_flow = _build_flow_from_source(req.repo_url, req.branch) except Exception as exc: raise HTTPException(status_code=400, detail=f"Failed to load flow from source: {exc}") # 2) Create or update a store-specific deployment deployment_name = f"clickstream-{req.store_id}" try: deployment_id = store_flow.deploy( name=deployment_name, work_pool_name="local-work-pool", tags=["clickstream-aggregation", "prod", f"store:{req.store_id}"], description=( "Clickstream Aggregation\n\n" "Args:\n" f" database: {req.database}\n" f" models: {req.models}\n" f" full_refresh (default): {req.default_full_refresh}\n" f" store_timezone_offset_minutes: {req.store_timezone_offset_minutes}\n" ), parameters={ "database": req.database, "models": req.models or "tag:clickstream", "full_refresh": req.default_full_refresh, "store_timezone_offset_minutes": req.store_timezone_offset_minutes, "is_complete_clickstream_run": req.is_complete_clickstream_run, }, concurrency_limit=ConcurrencyLimitConfig( limit=1, collision_strategy=ConcurrencyLimitStrategy.CANCEL_NEW ), ) except Exception as exc: raise HTTPException(status_code=500, detail=f"Deploy failed: {exc}") # 3) Trigger a bootstrap run that forces full table creation/refresh once # (overrides the deployment default full_refresh=False) try: async with get_client() as client: flow_run = await client.create_flow_run_from_deployment( deployment_id=deployment_id, parameters={ "database": req.database, "models": req.models or "tag:clickstream", "store_timezone_offset_minutes": req.store_timezone_offset_minutes, "is_complete_clickstream_run": req.is_complete_clickstream_run, "full_refresh": True, # override to create/refresh tables on first run }, name=f"bootstrap-{req.store_id}", tags=[f"store:{req.store_id}", "bootstrap"], ) return { "deployment_id": str(deployment_id), "bootstrap_flow_run_id": str(flow_run.id), "message": f"Provisioned {deployment_name} and started bootstrap run." } except Exception as exc: # Deployment is created; report only the run failure raise HTTPException( status_code=500, detail=f"Deployment created but failed to start bootstrap run: {exc}" ) ``` Notes - This is idempotent for deployment name. Calling it again with same
store_id
updates the deployment defaults (parameters, branch, description, tags, etc.) and you can choose whether to start another run. - You can add schedules later by passing
cron=...
,
interval=...
, or
schedules=[...]
into
.deploy()
if/when you want per-store scheduling. - If you want to keep some deployments defined in prefect.yaml for “known stores” and only use the API for new stores, that also works — both methods happily coexist in Prefect 3.x. 3) Wire service X to your Provisioning API - Service X calls POST /provision-store with the new store’s info as soon as integration completes. - The worker polls
local-work-pool
, pulls the code from your repo (auth via Secret block), and executes the bootstrap run. 4) Optional hardening and ops - Run Prefect Server and worker as systemd services on EC2 so they auto-restart. - Keep
PREFECT_API_URL
exported in the Provisioning API environment (e.g., http://localhost:4200/api).
- If you ever move to Docker or Kubernetes workers, swap the work pool type and pass appropriate
job_variables
(env, memory, cpu, etc.) in
.deploy()
. 5) Concurrency behavior You mentioned: - limit: 1 - collision_strategy: CANCEL_NEW In Prefect 3.x Python, that maps to:
Copy code
from prefect.client.schemas.objects import ConcurrencyLimitConfig, ConcurrencyLimitStrategy

concurrency_limit=ConcurrencyLimitConfig(
    limit=1,
    collision_strategy=ConcurrencyLimitStrategy.CANCEL_NEW
)
This ensures only one run per store is active at a time; excess runs are immediately canceled. 6) Triggering additional runs From anywhere in your stack, you can later trigger parameterized runs of an existing deployment:
Copy code
from prefect.client.orchestration import get_client

async def trigger_run(flow_name, deployment_name, params: dict):
    async with get_client() as client:
        deployment = await client.read_deployment_by_name(f"{flow_name}/{deployment_name}")
        flow_run = await client.create_flow_run_from_deployment(
            deployment_id=deployment.id,
            parameters=params,
            name="on-demand",
            tags=["manual"],
        )
        return flow_run.id
Trade-offs and an alternative - Per-store deployments are great for isolation and visibility. If you expect thousands of stores, consider a single shared deployment and just trigger runs with a
store_id
parameter — it’ll be lighter weight operationally. Your current pattern (one deployment per store) is totally fine at moderate scale and matches your preference. Quick checklist to validate the end-to-end path - Worker is polling
local-work-pool
and has network access to your Git repo and databases. - Secret block
dbt-git-repo-token
exists. - Provisioning API has
PREFECT_API_URL
set correctly. - Repo branch contains the flow at
flows/clickstream/clickstream.py:clickstream_dbt_run
. Questions to tailor the final setup - Do you want the provisioning to also attach schedules immediately (e.g., interval every 30 minutes), or do you prefer fully on-demand runs? - Is your repo always private and branch
dev
, or should the API accept a per-store branch? - Any store-specific dbt target/schema naming conventions we should encode (e.g., schema per store)? - Do you need to toggle
full_refresh
for periodic re-initialization, or is it strictly a one-time bootstrap? If you share those details, I can refine the provisioning endpoint (and the deployment defaults) to exactly fit your workflow.
k
@Marvin what is this python SDK client and REST API, what is the difference between each of them and for what purpose they are used
m
thought for 43.7 seconds
Great question. In Prefect there are two main ways to talk to the orchestration API: 1) Python SDK (Client + high-level helpers) - What it is: The Python package you’re already using (
prefect
). It includes: - A typed client for API calls - High-level helpers like
flow.deploy()
,
flow.from_source(...)
,
Secret.save()
,
client.create_flow_run_from_deployment(...)
, etc. - How it’s used: - From your Python code (flows, provisioning scripts/services) - The Prefect CLI also uses this under the hood - Why use it: - Convenience: fewer lines of code, type-checked models, retries, and sensible defaults - Features: helpers for Git-backed code via
flow.from_source(...)
, block management (
.save()
), schedules, concurrency, etc. - Returns Python objects you can work with immediately - When to choose it: - Your provisioning logic is in Python (easiest/most ergonomic) - You want to create/update deployments from a Git repo with a Secret block - You need to trigger runs, manage blocks, or update schedules from code 2) REST API (HTTP/JSON endpoints) - What it is: The raw HTTP endpoints exposed by your Prefect server: - CRUD for deployments, flows, blocks, flow runs, schedules, etc. - Examples:
POST /deployments
,
POST /deployments/{id}/create_flow_run
,
GET /deployments/name/{flow}/{deployment}
- How it’s used: - From any language or system (curl, Postman, Go/Java/Node, etc.) - Webhooks or platforms that can only make HTTP calls - Why use it: - Language-agnostic - Integrate Prefect directly into non-Python systems - When to choose it: - Service X is not Python and you don’t want to add a thin Python service - You need lowest-level control and are comfortable crafting JSON payloads Key differences - Ergonomics: SDK is higher-level and safer; REST is lower-level and more manual. - Language: SDK = Python only; REST = any language that can call HTTP. - Features: Everything the SDK does eventually hits REST under the hood, but the SDK adds powerful convenience (e.g.,
flow.from_source(...).deploy(...)
and block serialization). How this applies to your setup - You’re already in Python and using Prefect/DBT on EC2. The simplest, most reliable path is to build a small Python “Provisioning API” (e.g., FastAPI) that: - Uses the Python SDK to create per-store deployments via
flow.from_source(...).deploy(...)
- Enforces per-deployment concurrency (limit=1, CANCEL_NEW) - Immediately triggers a first run to create tables - If service X is not Python, it can either: - Call your Provisioning API (recommended), or - Call Prefect’s REST endpoints directly (you’ll need to craft the JSON and handle auth) Minimal examples - Python SDK: trigger a run from an existing deployment
Copy code
from prefect.client.orchestration import get_client

async def trigger():
    async with get_client() as client:
        dep = await client.read_deployment_by_name("clickstream_dbt_run/clickstream-2427b5-28")
        fr = await client.create_flow_run_from_deployment(
            deployment_id=dep.id,
            parameters={"full_refresh": True}
        )
        print(fr.id)
- REST API: trigger a run (curl)
Copy code
# For self-hosted Prefect Server OSS, typically no API key required by default.
# Adjust URL to your server and supply auth headers if applicable.

curl -X POST http://<your-prefect-server>:4200/api/deployments/<DEPLOYMENT_ID>/create_flow_run \
  -H "Content-Type: application/json" \
  -d '{
        "parameters": {"full_refresh": true},
        "name": "bootstrap-run",
        "tags": ["bootstrap"]
      }'
- REST API: read deployment by name (useful to get the ID)
Copy code
curl http://<your-prefect-server>:4200/api/deployments/name/<FLOW_NAME>/<DEPLOYMENT_NAME>
Notes on auth/config - Self-hosted Prefect Server (OSS): usually no API key; set
PREFECT_API_URL
for SDK usage (e.g., http://host:4200/api).
- Prefect Cloud: set both
PREFECT_API_URL
and
PREFECT_API_KEY
for SDK and add Authorization headers for REST. Docs - SDK overview: Prefect Docs - Deployments: Deployments - API reference: API Reference Recommendation for you - Implement the provisioning step in Python using the SDK. It’s the fastest way to: - Create per-store deployments from your Git repo - Apply concurrency = 1 with CANCEL_NEW - Trigger the first run for table creation - If service X can’t call Python, expose a small internal HTTP endpoint that wraps the SDK (thin FastAPI service). This keeps all logic consistent and avoids hand-crafting REST payloads.