<@ULVA73B9P> can you help me in correcting this if...
# marvin-ai
k
@Marvin can you help me in correcting this if there are any flaws in the code the logical flow of the code is as below i have defined one flow which will execute some tasks as operations on the database as a single transaction this is the flow @flow(log_prints=True) def transform_amazon_transactions( database: str, store_timezone_offset_minutes: str = "330" ): logger = get_run_logger() logger.info(f"Loading Environment Variables for Database: {database}") load_env_vars_dynamic( database=database, db_host = 'xyz.rds.amazonaws.com' _#explicitly passing the db_host of the dev database as the dataset is present in the dev only for now_ ) logger.info(f"Environment is Ready For Database: {database}") logger.info(f"Running Flow For Database: {database}") try: # get the engine after configuring the environment of the flow pg_conn = get_conn() # start the transaction txn = pg_conn.begin() handle_transaction_breakdown_processes(pg_conn) txn.commit() print(f" Transformation complete. Data saved to 'marketplaces' schema.\n") pg_conn.close() print("Connection closed") return 1 except Exception as e: logger.error(f"run failed: {str(e)}") raise this flow sets up the connection with the postgres using sqlalchemy and starts the transaction for the task handle_transaction_breakdown_processes now the task handle_transaction_breakdown_processes @task(log_prints=True) def handle_transaction_breakdown_processes(pg_conn): transactions = pd.read_sql("select * from marketplaces.amazon_raw_transactions", pg_conn) transactions_metadata = [] transactions_contexts = [] transactions_breakdowns = [] transactions_items_breakdowns = [] for index, transaction in transactions.iterrows(): _# Populate marketplaces.amazon_transactions_metadata_ transaction_metadata = process_and_save_transaction_metadata(transaction, pg_conn) _# Populate marketplaces.amazon_transactions_contexts_ transaction_contexts = process_and_save_transaction_contexts(transaction, pg_conn) _# Populate marketplaces.amazon_transactions_breakdowns_ transaction_breakdowns = process_and_save_transaction_breakdowns(transaction, pg_conn) _# Populate marketplaces.amazon_transaction_items_breakdowns_ transaction_items_breakdowns = process_and_save_transaction_items_breakdowns(transaction, pg_conn) gets raw data from the table and processes it and passes on to the four tasks which are process_and_save_transaction_metadata, process_and_save_transaction_contexts process_and_save_transaction_breakdowns and process_and_save_transaction_items_breakdowns which simply does some process and saves the process data in the table @task(log_prints=True) def process_and_save_transaction_breakdowns(transaction, pg_conn): processing.... save.... pd.DataFrame(transaction_breakdowns).to_sql( name="amazon_transactions_breakdowns", con=pg_conn, schema="marketplaces", index=False, if_exists="append" ) return transaction_breakdowns and likewise other three i want this to work as a single transaction means any error in the task should roll back
m
thought for 466.1 seconds
Short answer: you won’t be able to keep a single SQL transaction that spans multiple Prefect tasks. Tasks may run in different threads/processes/workers, and SQLAlchemy Connection/Session objects are not thread-safe. To guarantee “all-or-nothing,” put all DB work inside one task that owns the connection and the transaction, and call your helpers as plain functions (or via
task.fn
) so they run in the same thread and share the same transaction. Below is a refactor that preserves your intent and guarantees a rollback on any error. Key changes: - Open the DB connection and begin the transaction inside a single transactional task. - Call your “process_and_save_…” helpers as plain functions or with
.fn
if you keep them decorated with
@task
. - Pass the same connection to
pd.read_sql
and
to_sql
so they participate in the same transaction. - Don’t create the connection or start the transaction in the flow; create/use them in the task’s thread. Example ``` from prefect import flow, task, get_run_logger # from sqlalchemy import text # if you're on SQLAlchemy 2.0, use text() in read_sql # If your helpers are currently @task, either: # - remove @task so they are plain functions, OR # - keep @task but call them with
.fn(...)
inside the transactional task # Plain functions (recommended) ----------------------------------------------- def process_and_save_transaction_metadata(transaction, conn): # ... compute transaction_metadata # pd.DataFrame(transaction_metadata).to_sql(..., con=conn, schema="marketplaces", if_exists="append", index=False) return def process_and_save_transaction_contexts(transaction, conn): # ... return def process_and_save_transaction_breakdowns(transaction, conn): # ... # pd.DataFrame(transaction_breakdowns).to_sql(..., con=conn, schema="marketplaces", if_exists="append", index=False) return def process_and_save_transaction_items_breakdowns(transaction, conn): # ... return @task(log_prints=True) def run_transactional_breakdown(database: str, store_timezone_offset_minutes: str = "330"): """ Owns the connection and the transaction so all work is atomic. """ # IMPORTANT: open the connection inside the task (not in the flow) conn = get_conn() # should return a SQLAlchemy Connection (or Engine; see notes below) trans = conn.begin() # start a DB transaction try: # For SQLAlchemy 2.x, consider: pd.read_sql(text("select ..."), conn) transactions = pd.read_sql("select * from marketplaces.amazon_raw_transactions", conn) for _, transaction in transactions.iterrows(): # Call helpers as plain functions so they run in this same thread/transaction process_and_save_transaction_metadata(transaction, conn) process_and_save_transaction_contexts(transaction, conn) process_and_save_transaction_breakdowns(transaction, conn) process_and_save_transaction_items_breakdowns(transaction, conn) trans.commit() print(" Transformation complete. Data saved to 'marketplaces' schema.") except Exception as e: trans.rollback() # Prefect will mark the task as failed; re-raise for visibility raise finally: conn.close() print("Connection closed") @flow(log_prints=True) def transform_amazon_transactions(database: str, store_timezone_offset_minutes: str = "330"): logger = get_run_logger() logger.info(f"Loading Environment Variables for Database: {database}") load_env_vars_dynamic( database=database, db_host="xyz.rds.amazonaws.com" # explicit dev host while data is only in dev ) logger.info(f"Environment is Ready For Database: {database}") logger.info(f"Running Flow For Database: {database}") # Run everything that must be atomic in a single transactional task
run_transactional_breakdown(database=database, store_timezone_offset_minutes=store_timezone_offset_minutes)
Copy code
If you prefer to keep the four “process_and_save_…” as Prefect tasks, you must call them with `.fn(...)` inside the transactional task so they execute as plain functions (no orchestration), in the same thread and transaction:
process_and_save_transaction_breakdowns.fn(transaction, conn) ``` Notes and gotchas - Do not pass a SQLAlchemy Connection created in the flow into tasks. The flow runs in the main thread, but tasks run in worker threads; SQLAlchemy connections are not thread-safe and cannot cross threads. Always open the connection inside the task that uses it. - Prefer a context manager to reduce boilerplate: - If
get_conn()
returns an Engine:
with engine.begin() as conn: ...
commits on success, rolls back on exception. - If it returns a Connection:
with conn.begin(): ...
is equivalent. - Make sure
pd.to_sql(..., con=conn, ...)
uses the same
conn
from the active transaction. - If you truly need separate Prefect task runs for each step (for retries, mapping, etc.), you cannot reliably share a single DB transaction across them. In that case, consider: - Making each task idempotent and handling compensation on failure, or - Moving the multi-step transaction logic into a stored procedure and calling it from a single task. If you share what
get_conn()
returns (Engine vs Connection, SQLAlchemy 1.4 vs 2.x), I can tailor the `begin()`/context-manager version precisely and update the
pd.read_sql
call accordingly.