<@ULVA73B9P> Without `prefect-ssh` how do I use `p...
# ask-marvin
t
@Marvin Without
prefect-ssh
how do I use
prefect-shell
to execute a command to a remote machine via WinSSH?
m
thought for 176.0 seconds
Short answer: call your system’s SSH client from prefect-shell. prefect-shell runs commands locally on the worker; to run something on a remote host without prefect-ssh, you execute
ssh user@host "<remote command>"
. Key points for Windows (Win32-OpenSSH): - Use the Windows ssh.exe (installed with “OpenSSH Client”). - PowerShell can mangle quotes; either: - Use
shell="cmd"
to avoid PowerShell quoting, or - Use PowerShell’s stop-parsing operator
--%
so everything after it is passed verbatim to ssh. Examples 1) Windows worker -> Linux remote, using PowerShell with stop-parsing:
Copy code
from prefect import flow
from prefect_shell.commands import shell_run_command

@flow
def run_remote():
    # Add -i <key> if needed, and ensure the host is in known_hosts to avoid prompts
    result = shell_run_command(
        command='ssh --% ubuntu@1.2.3.4 "bash -lc \'hostname && whoami && ls -la /tmp\'"',
        shell="powershell",
        return_all=True,
    )
    return result
2) Windows worker -> Linux remote, using cmd.exe to keep quoting simple:
Copy code
from prefect import flow
from prefect_shell.commands import shell_run_command

@flow
def run_remote():
    result = shell_run_command(
        command='ssh ubuntu@1.2.3.4 "bash -lc \\"hostname && whoami && ls -la /tmp\\""',
        shell="cmd",
        return_all=True,
    )
    return result
3) Windows worker -> Windows remote (Win32-OpenSSH server defaults to PowerShell on many systems):
Copy code
from prefect import flow
from prefect_shell.commands import shell_run_command

@flow
def run_remote_windows():
    result = shell_run_command(
        command='ssh --% Administrator@win-host "powershell -NoProfile -Command \\"Get-ComputerInfo | Select-Object CsName,OsName,OsVersion -First 1\\""',
        shell="powershell",
        return_all=True,
    )
    return result
Tips - Authentication: include
-i C:\Path\to\id_ed25519
if you’re not using ssh-agent. Avoid passwords in commands. - Host key prompts: in non-interactive runs, pre-populate
known_hosts
or (only if acceptable) add
-o StrictHostKeyChecking=no
and a throwaway
UserKnownHostsFile
to avoid prompts. - Multiple commands: for Linux remotes,
bash -lc "<commands>"
is a reliable way to run a compound command with a login-like environment. - Observability:
return_all=True
returns all lines of output. You can also stream output to logs via
stream_level
. Docs - Prefect 3.x prefect-shell integration: prefect-shell docs If you share: - the OS/shell of your worker (PowerShell vs cmd) - the remote OS (Windows vs Linux) - your auth method (key vs password) …I can tailor the exact command and quoting for your setup.
t
@Marvin the machine running the worker is macOS, and I am trying to make that worker connect to my remote windows machine via WinSSH and execute some powershell query. So far I think we've been using username/password for winssh. If there is a existing and maintained
prefect-ssh
I would like to use that.
m
thought for 94.5 seconds
Thanks for the details. Today there isn’t an official, maintained
prefect-ssh
integration for Prefect 3.x. The common pattern is to use
prefect-shell
and call your system’s
ssh
client directly from the worker. Since your worker runs on macOS and your target is a Windows host (Win32-OpenSSH), you can run PowerShell remotely like this: - Prefer key-based auth (recommended). Password prompts won’t work in non-interactive runs. - If you must use username/password, see options below. Example: macOS worker -> Windows host over SSH (key-based)
Copy code
from prefect import flow
from prefect_shell.commands import shell_run_command

@flow
def run_remote_windows():
    # Replace host, user, and key path
    cmd = (
        'ssh -o BatchMode=yes '
        '-o StrictHostKeyChecking=accept-new '
        '-i ~/.ssh/id_ed25519 '
        'Administrator@win-host '
        'powershell -NoProfile -NonInteractive -ExecutionPolicy Bypass '
        '-Command "Get-ComputerInfo | Select-Object CsName,OsName,OsVersion -First 1 '
        '| ConvertTo-Json -Compress"'
    )

    result = shell_run_command(
        command=cmd,
        shell="bash",         # Explicitly use bash/zsh quoting on macOS
        return_all=True,      # Capture all lines
    )
    return result
Notes and tips - Auth: - Key-based is best for unattended workers: add your macOS worker’s public key to the Windows user’s
~\.ssh\authorized_keys
on the server and use
-i
or your ssh-agent. - Use
-o BatchMode=yes
to fail immediately if the key won’t work (prevents hanging on a password prompt). - Host keys: - First connection prompts can block execution. Use
-o StrictHostKeyChecking=accept-new
(OpenSSH 8.0+) or pre-populate
known_hosts
. - PowerShell command packaging: - Use
-NoProfile -NonInteractive -ExecutionPolicy Bypass -Command "<ps command>"
. - If your command contains double quotes, escape them or wrap carefully. Converting to JSON (
ConvertTo-Json
) is handy for parsing results. If you must use username/password - OpenSSH will prompt for a password interactively;
prefect-shell
won’t handle that prompt. You have two main options: 1) Use Paramiko in a Prefect task (no external prompt, supports password):
Copy code
from prefect import flow, task
  import paramiko

  @task
  def run_ps_over_paramiko(host, username, password, ps_command):
      client = paramiko.SSHClient()
      client.set_missing_host_key_policy(paramiko.AutoAddPolicy())
      client.connect(hostname=host, username=username, password=password)
      full = f'powershell -NoProfile -NonInteractive -ExecutionPolicy Bypass -Command "{ps_command}"'
      _, stdout, stderr = client.exec_command(full)
      out, err = stdout.read().decode(), stderr.read().decode()
      client.close()
      return out, err

  @flow
  def flow():
      return run_ps_over_paramiko(
          host="win-host",
          username="Administrator",
          password="***",
          ps_command='Get-ComputerInfo | Select-Object CsName,OsName,OsVersion -First 1 | ConvertTo-Json -Compress'
      )
2) Use
sshpass
(not recommended for security; may require a Homebrew tap on macOS). If you go this route, pass the password via environment variables or a secret store and be mindful of logs. Docs - Prefect 3.x shell integration: prefect-shell docs If you can switch to keys, I can help you craft the exact
ssh
command for your environment. If you must stay on password auth, I’d recommend the Paramiko task approach above for reliability.
t
@Marvin Can I just configure a shell block in prefect's UI and in my actual flow just call the shell operation command?
m
thought for 182.0 seconds
Short answer: there isn’t a built‑in “Shell” block to configure in the UI. In Prefect 3.x you typically just call `ShellOperation`/`shell_run_command` directly in your flow. If you want UI‑managed config, use Blocks (e.g., Secret, String, JSON) to store host/user/key/options and load them in your flow to build the SSH command string. What you can do today - Use
prefect-shell
directly in code (no block needed):
Copy code
from prefect import flow
from prefect_shell.commands import shell_run_command

@flow
def run_remote_windows():
    cmd = (
        'ssh -o BatchMode=yes '
        '-o StrictHostKeyChecking=accept-new '
        '-i ~/.ssh/id_ed25519 '
        'Administrator@win-host '
        'powershell -NoProfile -NonInteractive -ExecutionPolicy Bypass '
        '-Command "Get-ComputerInfo | Select-Object CsName,OsName,OsVersion -First 1 '
        '| ConvertTo-Json -Compress"'
    )
    return shell_run_command(command=cmd, shell="bash", return_all=True)
- Store configuration/secrets in Blocks and load them: - Create a Secret block in the UI named
winssh-password
(or store a key path, host, user in String/JSON blocks).
Copy code
from prefect import flow
from prefect.blocks.system import Secret
from prefect_shell.commands import shell_run_command

@flow
def run_remote_with_blocks():
    # Example with key path from a Secret block
    key_path = Secret.load("winssh-key-path").get()
    host = "win-host"  # or load from a String/JSON block
    user = "Administrator"

    cmd = (
        f'ssh -o BatchMode=yes -o StrictHostKeyChecking=accept-new -i {key_path} '
        f'{user}@{host} '
        'powershell -NoProfile -NonInteractive -ExecutionPolicy Bypass '
        '-Command "Get-ComputerInfo | Select-Object CsName,OsName,OsVersion -First 1 | ConvertTo-Json -Compress"'
    )
    return shell_run_command(command=cmd, shell="bash", return_all=True)
- Optional: define your own UI‑configurable “SSH Target” block (host/user/key/options) and register it so your team can fill it in once in the UI:
Copy code
# ssh_block.py
from prefect.blocks.core import Block

class SshTarget(Block):
    _block_type_name = "SSH Target"
    host: str
    user: str
    key_path: str | None = None
    extra_args: str = ""

# Register once:
# prefect block register -f ssh_block.py
# Then create an instance in the UI. In your flow:
# target = SshTarget.load("prod-windows")
# cmd = f'ssh {target.extra_args} -i {target.key_path} {target.user}@{target.host} ...'
CLI references: - List block types:
prefect block type ls
- Register custom blocks:
prefect block register -f ssh_block.py
- Generate UI creation link:
prefect block create <block_type_slug>
Docs: - Shell integration: prefect-shell docs - Blocks concepts: Blocks overview - CLI for blocks: prefect block CLI - Storing secrets: Store secrets Important note about password auth - System
ssh
will prompt interactively for a password; that won’t work in unattended flows. There’s no “shell block” that can inject a password into that prompt. - Recommended: switch to key‑based auth and keep using
prefect-shell
. - If you must use username/password, run SSH via a library that supports programmatic passwords (e.g., Paramiko in a Prefect task) instead of the system
ssh
client. If you want, I can help you: - set up a small custom “SSH Target” block, - or refactor your flow to load host/user/key from Blocks, - or provide a Paramiko-based task for password auth.