<@ULVA73B9P> If I hosted my Prefect flows on AWS E...
# ask-marvin
d
@Marvin If I hosted my Prefect flows on AWS ECS with a Prefect worker also hosted as an cluster service, would my flow be using that cluster task's resources? Moreover, if I decided to use a Dask task runner specified in my flow, when it runs on ESC would it be using the task resources?
m
thought for 47.5 seconds
Let me break down the answers to your questions: 1. Flow Resources and ECS Task Resources: Yes, when your flow runs on AWS ECS, it will use the resources (CPU, memory) specified in the ECS task definition for that specific flow run. The flow runs as a container within the ECS task, so it's constrained by the resources allocated in the task definition. This is separate from the worker's resources. 2. Dask Task Runner in ECS: When using a DaskTaskRunner within a flow running on ECS, there are a few important points to understand: - The Dask cluster would be initialized within the constraints of the ECS task's resources - The Dask workers would be limited to the CPU and memory allocated in your ECS task definition - You're essentially running both the Dask scheduler and workers within the same ECS task container Here's a simple example of how you might set up a flow with a DaskTaskRunner in this context:
Copy code
python
from prefect import flow
from prefect_dask import DaskTaskRunner

@flow(task_runner=DaskTaskRunner())
def my_flow():
    # Your flow code here
    pass
Important Considerations: - If you need more substantial distributed computing resources, you might want to consider setting up a separate Dask cluster rather than running it within the ECS task - The worker container's resources (the one polling for work) are separate from the flow run's resources - You can configure different resource allocations for different flows by using different ECS task definitions For optimal resource utilization, you should: 1. Carefully define your ECS task definition with appropriate CPU and memory allocations for your workload 2. Monitor resource usage to ensure you're not hitting constraints 3. Consider using separate task definitions for flows with different resource needs The links provided in the research contain detailed documentation about both ECS deployment and Dask integration with Prefect. Would you like me to elaborate on any specific aspect of resource allocation or task runner configuration?
d
@Marvin What is the max resource allocation I can have on an ECS task?
m
thought for 230.0 seconds
Based on the most current AWS documentation (as of 2024), here are the maximum resource allocations for ECS tasks: For AWS Fargate: - CPU: Up to 32 vCPUs (latest generation) - Memory: Up to 120 GiB - Supported CPU and memory combinations must follow AWS's defined values For ECS on EC2: - The maximum resources depend on the EC2 instance type you're using - Theoretical maximum is limited by the largest EC2 instance type available - Examples of high-memory instances can go up to: - Memory: Several terabytes (TB) with instances like
u-24tb1.metal
- CPU: Up to 448 vCPUs with instances like
p4de.24xlarge
Important Considerations: 1. Fargate Limitations: - Must use supported CPU/memory combinations - More predictable pricing but less flexibility - Better for moderate workloads 2. EC2 Advantages: - Much higher resource limits possible - More cost-effective for large, consistent workloads - Greater flexibility in instance types 3. Cost Implications: - Higher resource allocations generally mean higher costs - EC2 might be more cost-effective for high-resource tasks - Consider spot instances for EC2 to reduce costs 4. Best Practices: - Start with a reasonable allocation and scale based on monitoring - Use appropriate instance types for your workload - Consider using auto-scaling policies For the most up-to-date and detailed information about specific instance types and their capabilities, I recommend checking: 1. AWS ECS Task Definition Parameters 2. AWS EC2 Instance Types 3. AWS Fargate Platform Versions Would you like me to provide more specific information about any particular instance type or resource configuration?