<@ULVA73B9P> I want to return data in a Failed sta...
# ask-marvin
t
@Marvin I want to return data in a Failed state, but I get an error saying that my data cannot be resolved into an exception. How do I get around this?
m
thought for 68.4 seconds
Let me help you with this issue. The "cannot be resolved into an exception" error typically occurs when you're trying to return data alongside a failure state without properly structuring it. Here's how to properly handle this: 1. Using Exception Handling (Recommended Approach):
Copy code
python
from prefect import flow, task
from prefect.states import Failed

@task
def my_task():
    try:
        # Your task logic here
        result = "some calculation"
        if something_went_wrong:
            raise ValueError("Something went wrong")
        return result
    except Exception as e:
        # You can include both the error and additional data
        return Failed(
            message="Task failed with error",
            data={"error": str(e), "additional_data": "some context"}
        )

@flow
def my_flow():
    result = my_task()
    return result
2. Using State Functions:
Copy code
python
from prefect import flow, task
from prefect.states import Failed

@task
def my_task():
    try:
        # Your task logic here
        raise ValueError("Something went wrong")
    except Exception as e:
        # Create a Failed state with both the exception and data
        return Failed(
            message="Task failed",
            data={"my_data": "some data"},
            exception=e
        )
Key points to remember: - Always include the actual exception in the Failed state if you have one - Structure your data as a dictionary when including additional information - Use try/except blocks to handle the failure gracefully - Make sure your data is serializable (can be converted to JSON) If you're still getting the error, it would be helpful if you could share: 1. The specific code that's causing the error 2. The exact error message you're receiving 3. What kind of data you're trying to return This would allow me to provide more targeted assistance for your specific case.
t
@Marvin this is the error I'm getting. I'm trying to pass an object as the
data
in a Failed sta
Copy code
TypeError: Unexpected result for failed state: ... —— MainFragSwapFlowState cannot be resolved into an exception
Copy code
return Failed(message=failure_msg + msg + "\n" + flow_link_msg, data=fs)
m
thought for 45.8 seconds
I understand now - you're trying to pass a custom object (
MainFragSwapFlowState
) directly as data in a Failed state. The error occurs because Prefect needs the data to be serializable (typically JSON-serializable). Here's how you can fix this: 1. Convert the object to a dictionary:
Copy code
python
from prefect.states import Failed

# Convert your object to a dictionary with only the relevant data
fs_dict = {
    "attribute1": fs.attribute1,
    "attribute2": fs.attribute2,
    # ... other relevant attributes
}

return Failed(
    message=failure_msg + msg + "\n" + flow_link_msg,
    data=fs_dict
)
2. Add a serialization method to your class:
Copy code
python
class MainFragSwapFlowState:
    def to_dict(self):
        return {
            "attribute1": self.attribute1,
            "attribute2": self.attribute2,
            # ... other relevant attributes
        }

# Then in your flow:
return Failed(
    message=failure_msg + msg + "\n" + flow_link_msg,
    data=fs.to_dict()
)
3. If you need to preserve specific object attributes:
Copy code
python
return Failed(
    message=failure_msg + msg + "\n" + flow_link_msg,
    data={
        "state_type": type(fs).__name__,
        "attributes": vars(fs),  # This gets all instance variables
        # Add any other specific data you need
    }
)
The key point is that the
data
parameter in a Failed state must be serializable (typically to JSON). Complex objects need to be converted to basic Python types (dictionaries, lists, strings, numbers, etc.) before being passed to the Failed state. If you need help with the specific attributes of your
MainFragSwapFlowState
object that you want to preserve, let me know and I can provide more targeted guidance.
t
@Marvin why does it not need to be that way when passing data to a
Completed
state?
m
thought for 34.1 seconds
Ah, this is an interesting architectural decision in Prefect! The difference comes down to how Prefect handles different states internally: 1. Completed States: - Can handle non-serializable data because the data typically stays within the same process - Only needs to be serialized if you explicitly configure result storage or persistence - Primarily used for passing data between tasks in memory 2. Failed States: - Must be serializable because Prefect needs to: - Store failure information for debugging - Pass error information through the orchestration layer - Support retry mechanisms - Enable proper error reporting and logging - May need to be transmitted between different systems or stored for later analysis This is why you can do:
Copy code
python
@task
def my_task():
    complex_object = MyComplexClass()
    return complex_object  # This works fine and returns a Completed state
But need to serialize for failures:
Copy code
python
@task
def my_task():
    try:
        complex_object = MyComplexClass()
        raise ValueError("Something went wrong")
    except Exception as e:
        return Failed(
            message="Task failed",
            data={"object_data": complex_object.to_dict()}  # Need to serialize
        )
It's a bit like the difference between returning a value from a function (which can be anything) versus logging an error (which needs to be in a format that can be written to logs and transmitted). If you need to preserve the full state of your complex object in a Failed state, you might want to: 1. Implement proper serialization methods for your class 2. Store the complex object elsewhere (like a database) and only include a reference in the Failed state 3. Or extract only the essential information needed for error handling
t
@Marvin Uh oh...
Copy code
TypeError: Unexpected result for failed state: {'error': "Encountered an exception while invoking the 'MOVE_FRAG_ACCOUNTS' flow: 'MOVE_FRAG_ACCOUNTS' is not implemented"} —— dict cannot be resolved into an exception
That doesn't seem to be correct.
m
thought for 55.4 seconds
Ah, I see the issue now. When creating a Failed state, we need to include both the
data
and the actual
exception
. Here's how to fix it:
Copy code
python
from prefect.states import Failed

# Option 1: Include the actual exception
exception = NotImplementedError("'MOVE_FRAG_ACCOUNTS' is not implemented")
return Failed(
    message="Flow execution failed",
    data={'error': str(exception)},
    exception=exception  # This is the key part we were missing!
)

# Option 2: Use exception_to_failed_state
from prefect.states import exception_to_failed_state

exception = NotImplementedError("'MOVE_FRAG_ACCOUNTS' is not implemented")
failed_state = exception_to_failed_state(
    exc=exception,
    message="Flow execution failed",
    data={'error': str(exception)}
)
return failed_state
The error you're seeing occurs because Prefect expects an actual exception object to be present when creating a Failed state. Simply passing a dictionary with error information isn't enough - Prefect needs to know what type of exception caused the failure. This is a bit counterintuitive, but it's designed this way to ensure proper error tracking and handling in Prefect's orchestration layer. The
exception
parameter is used to maintain the full exception context, while the
data
parameter can contain additional information you want to store alongside the error. Let me know if you need help modifying your specific code to include the proper exception handling!
t
@Marvin is there a way that I can prevent prefect from raising an exception when a Failed state is returned from a flow?
m
Error: status_code: 529, model_name: claude-3-5-sonnet-latest, body: {'type': 'error', 'error': {'type': 'overloaded_error', 'message': 'Overloaded'}}
Error: status_code: 529, model_name: claude-3-5-sonnet-latest, body: {'type': 'error', 'error': {'type': 'overloaded_error', 'message': 'Overloaded'}}