<@ULVA73B9P>, I'm crrently using workpools to run ...
# ask-community
s
@Marvin, I'm crrently using workpools to run my flows. When ever i run a flow i'll pass a server host name as one of the parameter saying ads_address to tell which server it should connect. Based on this paramerer i'll be decding to which server i want to connect from the flow and run my logic. Here i'll be having 8 ads servers to connect and i'll be having multiple flows(20000+) flows to trigger daily and share the load accross all the ads servers. And one more thing is that i cant run more 300 flows to run in a single ads. Concurrently can run only 300 jobs in each ads_server. Here how can i segregate this load distibution among the ads servers via workpool concept. Give me a clever solution for this. My prefect is hosted in ecs as a service. I'm using aws ecs type wiyh my pool to run the flows here.
m
thought for 74.8 seconds
Based on your requirements and the research, I'll propose a solution using work queues within your ECS work pool. Here's a clever approach to distribute your 20,000+ flows across 8 ADS servers while maintaining the 300-concurrent-job limit: 1. Work Pool Structure:
Copy code
python
# Create one main ECS work pool
from prefect import WorkPool

work_pool = WorkPool.create(
    name="ads-workpool",
    work_queue_count=8,  # One queue per ADS server
    type="ecs",
)
2. Work Queue Setup: Create 8 work queues (one for each ADS server) with concurrency limits:
Copy code
python
from prefect.client import get_client

async def setup_work_queues():
    client = get_client()
    
    # Create a queue for each ADS server
    for i in range(1, 9):
        await client.create_work_queue(
            name=f"ads-server-{i}-queue",
            work_pool_name="ads-workpool",
            concurrency_limit=300  # Enforce 300 concurrent jobs limit
        )
3. Flow Deployment Strategy: Here's how to deploy your flows with server assignment:
Copy code
python
from prefect import flow
from prefect.deployments import Deployment

@flow
def your_flow(ads_address: str):
    # Your existing flow logic here
    pass

# Deploy the flow multiple times, each targeting a specific work queue
def deploy_flow(flow_name: str, queue_name: str):
    return Deployment.build_from_flow(
        flow=your_flow,
        name=f"{flow_name}-{queue_name}",
        work_queue_name=queue_name,
        work_pool_name="ads-workpool",
        parameters={"ads_address": f"ads-server-{queue_name}"}
    )
4. Load Balancing Strategy: Here's a smart way to distribute your flows:
Copy code
python
from prefect.client import get_client
import random

async def get_optimal_queue():
    client = get_client()
    
    # Get all queues and their current running jobs
    queues = await client.read_work_queues()
    queue_loads = {}
    
    for queue in queues:
        stats = await client.read_work_queue_stats(queue.id)
        queue_loads[queue.name] = stats.running_runs_count
    
    # Find queues with least load
    min_load = min(queue_loads.values())
    available_queues = [
        queue for queue, load in queue_loads.items() 
        if load == min_load
    ]
    
    # Randomly select from least loaded queues
    return random.choice(available_queues)

@flow
async def schedule_flow_run(flow_name: str):
    optimal_queue = await get_optimal_queue()
    # Schedule the flow run on the optimal queue
    return await create_flow_run(
        flow_name=flow_name,
        work_queue_name=optimal_queue
    )
5. Deployment Configuration: For your ECS setup, ensure your work pool configuration includes:
Copy code
python
work_pool_config = {
    "type": "ecs",
    "cluster": "your-ecs-cluster",
    "vpc": "your-vpc-id",
    "task_definition": "your-task-definition",
    "container_name": "your-container-name",
    "launch_type": "FARGATE",  # or EC2 based on your setup
    "execution_role_arn": "your-execution-role-arn",
    "task_role_arn": "your-task-role-arn",
}
Key Benefits of this Solution: 1. Automatic Load Balancing: The system will automatically distribute flows across available ADS servers while respecting the 300-concurrent-job limit. 2. Isolation: Each ADS server has its dedicated work queue, preventing resource conflicts. 3. Scalability: Easy to add or remove ADS servers by managing work queues. 4. Monitoring: You can easily monitor the load on each server through queue statistics. Additional Recommendations: 1. Health Checks: Implement health checks for your ADS servers and dynamically adjust queue availability. 2. Queue Tags: Use tags to mark queues for specific types of flows if needed. 3. Monitoring: Set up alerts when queues approach their concurrency limits. 4. Retry Logic: Implement retry logic that considers server availability. To implement this in your ECS environment:
1. Ensure your ECS task definitions include the necessary environment variables for ADS server connections. 2. Use IAM roles that allow your tasks to access both Prefect and your ADS servers. 3. Consider using ECS service auto-scaling to handle worker demand. Would you like me to elaborate on any part of this solution or provide more specific details about implementing any of these components?
s
@Marvin No, here My workflow is like. My flows contains a parameter called ads_server. this is a str values where i will give a string saying "dev1". So whenever i trigger the flow, in my flow logic i have a logic in place to append path for this parameter like [/path/to/cfg/]/dev1.cfg. I'll pouplate this path and i'll be having some configurations variables and all and also the ads actual hostname in that. So i'll running a commabd using suprocess with this cfg file to connect to ads like "ats cfg date user-name password". so whatever i pass dev1 to my flow parameter then it will go connect to de1 ads server. Similarly i'll having respective cfg files for all the ads servers(8). So in this case i want to handle the ads load distribution to utilize most of the ads resources while i triger the flows. Let me kno a very good clever approch here for my case.
m
thought for 121.5 seconds
Based on your specific setup, here's a smarter solution that leverages Prefect's capabilities to distribute load across your ADS servers: 1. First, let's define your base flow structure:
Copy code
python
from prefect import flow, task
import subprocess
from typing import Literal
import asyncio
from prefect.client import get_client

# Define valid ADS servers as literal types for better type checking
AdsServer = Literal["dev1", "dev2", "dev3", "dev4", "dev5", "dev6", "dev7", "dev8"]

@task
async def get_ads_server_load(server: str) -> int:
    """
    Get the current number of running flows for a specific ADS server
    """
    client = get_client()
    runs = await client.read_flow_runs(
        flow_run_filter=dict(
            tags=[f"ads_server:{server}"],
            state={"type": "RUNNING"}
        )
    )
    return len(runs)

@task
async def select_optimal_ads_server() -> str:
    """
    Select the ADS server with the lowest current load
    """
    servers = ["dev1", "dev2", "dev3", "dev4", "dev5", "dev6", "dev7", "dev8"]
    loads = await asyncio.gather(*[get_ads_server_load(server) for server in servers])
    
    # Create server-load pairs and find the server with minimum load
    server_loads = list(zip(servers, loads))
    optimal_server = min(server_loads, key=lambda x: x[1])[0]
    
    return optimal_server

@flow(name="your-main-flow")
async def your_flow(ads_server: str | None = None):
    """
    Your main flow with automatic ADS server selection if not specified
    """
    # If ads_server is not provided, automatically select the optimal one
    if ads_server is None:
        ads_server = await select_optimal_ads_server()
    
    # Configure the cfg file path based on the selected server
    cfg_path = f"/path/to/cfg/{ads_server}.cfg"
    
    # Your existing subprocess logic
    try:
        result = subprocess.run(
            ["ats", "cfg", "date", "user-name", "password"],
            env={"CFG_FILE": cfg_path},
            check=True,
            capture_output=True,
            text=True
        )
        # Your flow logic here
        
    except subprocess.CalledProcessError as e:
        # Handle error appropriately
        raise Exception(f"Failed to connect to ADS server {ads_server}: {str(e)}")
2. Create a Work Pool Configuration:
Copy code
python
from prefect import WorkPool

# Create a single work pool for all your flows
work_pool = WorkPool.create(
    name="ads-workpool",
    type="ecs",
    base_job_template={
        "cluster": "your-ecs-cluster",
        "task_definition": "your-task-definition",
        "container_name": "your-container-name",
        "launch_type": "FARGATE",  # or EC2
    }
)
3. Create a Smart Deployment Manager:
Copy code
python
from prefect import flow
from datetime import timedelta
import asyncio

@flow(name="smart-flow-distributor")
async def distribute_flows(flow_runs_to_create: int):
    """
    Intelligently distribute multiple flow runs across ADS servers
    """
    client = get_client()
    
    # Create flow runs with automatic server selection
    flow_runs = []
    for _ in range(flow_runs_to_create):
        # Let the flow itself handle server selection
        flow_run = await client.create_flow_run(
            flow_name="your-main-flow",
            parameters={},  # Let the flow auto-select the server
            tags=["auto_distributed"]
        )
        flow_runs.append(flow_run)
        
        # Add a small delay to prevent overwhelming the system
        await asyncio.sleep(0.1)
    
    return flow_runs

# Example usage for scheduling multiple flows
@flow(name="schedule-daily-flows")
async def schedule_daily_flows():
    """Schedule your 20000+ daily flows"""
    await distribute_flows(flow_runs_to_create=20000)
4. Monitoring and Control System: ```python from prefect import flow, task from prefect.client import get_client @task async def get_ads_server_stats(): """ Get current statistics for all ADS servers """
servers = ["dev1", "dev2", "dev3", "dev4", "dev5", "dev6", "dev7", "dev8"] stats = {} for server in servers: running_count = await get_ads_server_load(server) stats[server] = { "running_flows": running_count, "available_slots": 300 - running_count } return stats @flow(name="monitor-ads-servers") async def monitor_servers(): """ Monitor and log ADS server utilization """ stats = await get_ads_server_stats() # Log or alert if any server is approaching capacity for server, data in stats.items(): if data["running_flows"] > 250: # Alert at 83% capacity print(f"WARNING: {server} is approaching capacity: {data['running_flows']}/300") return stats
Copy code
*Key Features of this Solution:*

1. *Automatic Load Balancing:*
   - The system automatically selects the least loaded ADS server when no server is specified
   - Maintains even distribution across all 8 servers
   - Respects the 300-concurrent-job limit per server

2. *Flexibility:*
   - You can still manually specify an ADS server when needed
   - Easy to add or remove servers from the pool
   - Handles both automated and manual flow triggers

3. *Monitoring and Control:*
   - Real-time tracking of server utilization
   - Built-in alerts for capacity issues
   - Easy to add custom monitoring metrics

4. *Error Handling:*
   - Graceful handling of connection failures
   - Automatic retries can be added if needed
   - Clear error reporting

To use this system:

1. *For Manual Flow Runs:*
```python
# Let it auto-select the server
await your_flow()

# Or specify a server
await your_flow(ads_server="dev1")
2. For Bulk Scheduling:
Copy code
python
# Schedule all your daily flows
await schedule_daily_flows()
3. For Monitoring:
Copy code
python
# Check current server utilization
stats = await monitor_servers()
This solution provides: - Automatic load balancing across your 8 ADS servers - Respect for the 300-concurrent-job limit - Easy monitoring and management - Flexibility to override automatic selection when needed - Scalability for your 20,000+ daily flows Would you like me to explain any part of this solution in more detail or help with implementing specific components?