<@ULVA73B9P> Can I pass complex objects to a prefe...
# ask-marvin
g
@Marvin Can I pass complex objects to a prefect remote deployment? I imagine under the hood these are RPCs so how would prefect solve something like the following example:
Copy code
from prefect.deployments import run_deployment

class ComplexObj:
   def __init__(self):
      ...
   
   def method1(self):
      ...

   etc

my_object = ComplexObj()

my_flow_run = run_deployment(
   name="my-flow"
   parameters={
      "some_str": "just_a_string",
      "some_int": 25,
      "some_complex_obj": my_object,
   },
   timeout=0,
)
Let's assume "my-flow" is implemented in an entirely different codebase and can accept anything as parameter for "some_complex_obj". Would this work?
m
thought for 64.6 seconds
In your example, passing a complex custom object (
ComplexObj
) directly to a remote deployment would not work out of the box. Here's why and what you can do about it: 1. Serialization Limitations: - Prefect needs to serialize parameters to send them across the network - By default, Prefect uses JSON serialization which can only handle basic Python types (strings, numbers, lists, dictionaries, etc.) - Custom objects like your
ComplexObj
cannot be automatically serialized to JSON 2. Solutions: a) Convert to Serializable Format:
Copy code
python
   # Convert your complex object to a dictionary before passing
   my_object_dict = {
       "attribute1": my_object.attribute1,
       "attribute2": my_object.attribute2,
   }

   my_flow_run = run_deployment(
       name="my-flow",
       parameters={
           "some_str": "just_a_string",
           "some_int": 25,
           "some_complex_obj": my_object_dict,  # Pass the dictionary instead
       },
       timeout=0,
   )
b) Custom Serialization:
Copy code
python
   from prefect.serializers import Serializer
   
   class ComplexObjSerializer(Serializer):
       def dumps(self, obj):
           # Convert your object to bytes
           return your_serialization_logic(obj)
           
       def loads(self, blob):
           # Convert bytes back to your object
           return your_deserialization_logic(blob)
3. Best Practices: - Keep deployment parameters simple and serializable - If you need to pass complex objects, consider: - Breaking them down into basic types - Passing identifiers/references and reconstructing the objects in the flow - Using a shared storage system (database, object store) to store complex objects 4. Important Considerations: - The receiving flow must have access to the
ComplexObj
class definition - Any dependencies required by your complex object must be available in the flow's environment - Consider versioning implications if the object structure changes Remember: The simpler your parameter structure, the more reliable your deployments will be. Consider whether you really need to pass the entire complex object, or if you can pass just the essential data in a simpler format.
g
@Marvin How would I solve this then with object storage?
m
thought for 57.1 seconds
Here's a practical solution for handling complex objects with object storage in Prefect: 1. First, set up an S3 (or similar) Block:
Copy code
python
from prefect_aws import S3Bucket
from prefect.blocks.system import JSON

# Create and save your storage block
s3_block = S3Bucket(
    bucket_name="your-bucket",
    credentials={
        "aws_access_key_id": "your-key",
        "aws_secret_access_key": "your-secret"
    }
)
s3_block.save("my-storage")
2. Modify your flow to use object storage:
Copy code
python
import pickle
from prefect import flow, task
from prefect_aws import S3Bucket

@task
def store_complex_object(obj):
    # Serialize your object
    serialized_obj = pickle.dumps(obj)
    
    # Get the storage block
    s3_block = S3Bucket.load("my-storage")
    
    # Generate a unique key for this object
    object_key = f"complex_objects/{obj.__class__.__name__}_{id(obj)}.pkl"
    
    # Store the object
    s3_block.write_path(object_key, serialized_obj)
    
    return object_key

@task
def retrieve_complex_object(object_key):
    # Get the storage block
    s3_block = S3Bucket.load("my-storage")
    
    # Retrieve the serialized object
    serialized_obj = s3_block.read_path(object_key)
    
    # Deserialize and return
    return pickle.loads(serialized_obj)

@flow
def workflow_with_complex_object():
    # Create your complex object
    my_object = ComplexObj()
    
    # Store it and get the reference
    object_key = store_complex_object(my_object)
    
    # Now you can pass the key to your remote deployment
    remote_flow_run = run_deployment(
        name="my-flow",
        parameters={
            "some_str": "just_a_string",
            "some_int": 25,
            "complex_obj_key": object_key,  # Pass the storage key instead of the object
        },
        timeout=0,
    )
3. In your remote flow, retrieve the object:
Copy code
python
@flow
def my_flow(some_str: str, some_int: int, complex_obj_key: str):
    # Retrieve the complex object
    complex_obj = retrieve_complex_object(complex_obj_key)
    
    # Now you can use the object
    complex_obj.method1()
    # ... rest of your flow logic
Important Considerations: 1. Security: - Ensure proper access controls on your S3 bucket - Consider encryption at rest for sensitive data - Use appropriate IAM roles/permissions 2. Performance: - Large objects might impact flow execution time - Consider cleanup tasks for temporary objects - Use appropriate S3 storage classes based on access patterns 3. Reliability: - Add error handling for storage/retrieval operations - Consider object expiration policies - Implement retry logic for network operations 4. Cost: - Monitor storage usage and implement cleanup - Use appropriate S3 storage classes - Consider implementing TTL (Time To Live) for temporary objects This approach provides several benefits: - Handles objects of any size or complexity - Maintains separation of concerns - Provides persistence if needed - Works across different execution environments - Allows for versioning and tracking of objects Remember to handle cleanup of stored objects when they're no longer needed, either through explicit deletion tasks or S3 lifecycle policies.