<@ULVA73B9P> I have a prefect flow running 10 task...
# ask-marvin
s
@Marvin I have a prefect flow running 10 tasks in parallel on Ray via EC2. When I execute the following code by
python 3 file.py
, it works perfectly. I want to create a deployment out of this that I can run and trigger from the UI. I am happy to use docker for this and upload my docker file to a registry. I am on prefect 2.x and want to stay on it. How?
Copy code
import time
from prefect import flow, task
from prefect_ray import RayTaskRunner

@task
def shout(number):
    time.sleep(0.5)
    print(f"#{number}")

@flow(task_runner=RayTaskRunner(
        address="<ray://1.2.2.3:10001>",
        init_kwargs={"runtime_env": {"pip3": ["prefect-ray"]}},
    ),
)
def count_to(highest_number):
    futures = [shout.submit(number) for number in range(highest_number)]
    for future in futures:
        future.wait()  # Ensure all tasks complete

if __name__ == "__main__":
    count_to(10)
m
To create a deployment for your Prefect flow that can be triggered from the UI, you can follow these steps: 1. Dockerize Your Flow: - Ensure you have Docker installed and running. - Create a
Dockerfile
that installs your dependencies and includes your flow code. 2. Build the Docker Image: - Use Docker to build your image. You can specify the registry path if you're using a registry other than Docker Hub. 3. Create a Deployment: - Use Prefect's CLI or UI to create a deployment. You can specify the Docker image in the deployment configuration. - Ensure your deployment includes the necessary infrastructure settings to run on Ray and EC2. 4. Push to a Docker Registry: - Authenticate and push your Docker image to a registry accessible by your deployment environment. 5. Trigger from the UI: - Once your deployment is created and your Docker image is available, you can trigger flow runs from the Prefect UI. For detailed guidance, refer to the Prefect deployment documentation and Docker deployment guide. Additionally, ensure your Ray setup is correctly configured as per the Ray task runner guide. Wouldn't it be nice if things just worked without all this setup? But alas, that's the life of an engineer.
s
@Marvin I dont think I understand prefect properly. I was able to run this without workpools so far because I triggered the flow locally. Correct?
m
Yes, that's correct. When you run a Prefect flow locally, it executes directly on your machine without needing work pools or additional infrastructure. This is why you could run your flow using
python 3 file.py
without any issues. However, when you want to deploy your flow to be managed and triggered via the Prefect UI or Prefect Cloud, you need to set up a deployment. This involves specifying where and how your flow should run, which might include using work pools if you're leveraging distributed systems like Ray on EC2. In essence, running locally bypasses many of the deployment complexities, but for managed execution and scalability, setting up deployments with work pools and infrastructure is necessary. If only everything were as simple as running things locally. But then, where would the fun be in that?
s
@Marvin But the thing is, I see my flow on the prefect cloud even when I run it locally. and of course I see it on my ec2 ray cluster.
m
When you run your flow locally and see it on Prefect Cloud, it means that your local environment is connected to Prefect Cloud. This connection allows Prefect to track and display your flow runs in the cloud interface, even though the execution is happening on your local machine. Here's how it works: 1. Local Execution with Cloud Tracking: - When you execute a flow locally, Prefect can still report the flow's state and logs to Prefect Cloud, assuming your environment is authenticated with Prefect Cloud. 2. Ray Cluster Execution: - Your tasks are executed on the Ray cluster, but Prefect still manages the flow orchestration and tracking, allowing you to view the flow's progress and results on Prefect Cloud. This setup provides the best of both worlds: local execution control with centralized tracking and orchestration from Prefect Cloud. It's a common pattern for development and testing. The Prefect Cloud acts as an orchestration layer, giving you visibility and control over your flows, regardless of where they are executed. It seems like you've got a pretty efficient setup going—who knew orchestration could be so... orchestrated?
s
@Marvin okay but I want to be able to start the flow itself programmatically remotely. Like perhaps on a schedule.
m
To programmatically start your Prefect flow remotely or on a schedule, you can use Prefect's scheduling and client capabilities. Here's how you can achieve this: 1. Set Up a Deployment with a Schedule: - You can define a schedule in your deployment configuration, either directly in the Prefect UI or by using a
prefect.yaml
file. The schedule can be specified using cron syntax or other scheduling options. - Example
prefect.yaml
snippet:
Copy code
yaml
     deployments:
       - name: my-deployment
         entrypoint: path/to/flow.py:count_to
         schedules:
           - cron: "0 12 * * *"  # Runs every day at noon
             timezone: "America/New_York"
             active: true
- More details on scheduling can be found here. 2. Programmatically Trigger a Flow Run: - You can use the Prefect client to create a flow run from a deployment programmatically. This can be done using the
create_flow_run_from_deployment
method. - Example code:
Copy code
python
     from prefect.client import get_client
     import asyncio

     async def trigger_flow_run(deployment_id):
         async with get_client() as client:
             flow_run = await client.create_flow_run_from_deployment(deployment_id=deployment_id)
             print(f"Flow run created with ID: {flow_run.id}")

     asyncio.run(trigger_flow_run("your-deployment-id"))
- More information on using the client can be found here. By setting up a deployment with a schedule or using the client to trigger runs, you can automate the execution of your flows without manual intervention. It's like having a personal assistant, but without the need for coffee breaks.
s
@Marvin I wanna just setup a simple deployment for now with no schedules. Just a deployment I can 'run' from the UI.
m
To set up a simple deployment for your Prefect flow that you can run from the UI without any schedules, follow these steps: 1. Create a
prefect.yaml
file:
- This file will define your deployment configuration. Here's a basic example for your flow:
Copy code
yaml
   deployments:
     - name: my-simple-deployment
       entrypoint: path/to/your_script.py:count_to
2. Build and Register the Deployment: - Use the Prefect CLI to build and register your deployment. Run the following command in your terminal:
Copy code
bash
     prefect deployment build -n my-simple-deployment -p path/to/your_script.py:count_to
- This command will package your flow and create a deployment that Prefect Cloud can manage. 3. Push Your Docker Image (if needed): - If your flow requires a Docker image, ensure it's built and pushed to a registry accessible by Prefect. 4. Run the Deployment from the UI: - Once the deployment is registered, it will appear in the Prefect UI under Deployments. - You can manually trigger a flow run from the UI by selecting your deployment and clicking "Run". This setup allows you to manage and trigger your flow runs from the Prefect UI without any scheduling. It's straightforward and provides a centralized interface to control your flow executions. For more details, you can review the Prefect deployment documentation. It's almost like magic, but with a bit more YAML.
s
@Marvin do i need to define a workpool? I ideally dont want to
m
In Prefect 2.x, defining a work pool is not strictly necessary if you're running your flows locally or if your deployment's infrastructure doesn't require it. Work pools are typically used to manage and distribute work across different execution environments, like Kubernetes, ECS, or other cloud infrastructure. For a simple deployment that you want to trigger from the UI without specific infrastructure requirements, you can skip defining a work pool. Your flow will run using the default execution environment or any environment you've previously set up. Here's a concise setup without a work pool: 1.
prefect.yaml
for Deployment:
Copy code
yaml
   deployments:
     - name: my-simple-deployment
       entrypoint: path/to/your_script.py:count_to
2. Register the Deployment: - Use the Prefect CLI to register your deployment:
Copy code
bash
     prefect deployment build -n my-simple-deployment -p path/to/your_script.py:count_to
3. Run from the UI: - Once registered, your deployment will appear in the Prefect UI, and you can trigger runs directly from there. This approach keeps things simple and allows you to focus on running your flows without managing additional infrastructure layers. It's like taking the scenic route—simple and effective.
s
@Marvin Okay can you give me the complete YAML file?
m
Certainly! Here's a complete example of a
prefect.yaml
file for a simple deployment that you can run from the Prefect UI without any schedules or work pools:
Copy code
yaml
deployments:
  - name: my-simple-deployment
    entrypoint: path/to/your_script.py:count_to
    description: A simple deployment for my flow
    parameters:
      highest_number: 10  # Default parameter value for your flow
    tags: []
    work_queue_name: default  # Use the default work queue
### Key Components: -
name
: The name of your deployment, which will appear in the Prefect UI. -
entrypoint
: The path to your flow script and the specific flow function within that script. -
description
: (Optional) A brief description of your deployment. -
parameters
: Default parameters for your flow, which can be overridden when you trigger a run. -
tags
: (Optional) Tags for organizing your deployment. -
work_queue_name
: Specifies the work queue to use. Here, it defaults to
default
, which means it will use the default execution environment. ### Steps to Deploy: 1. Save this
prefect.yaml
file in your project directory. 2. Register the deployment using the Prefect CLI:
Copy code
bash
   prefect deployment build -n my-simple-deployment -p path/to/your_script.py:count_to
3. Trigger the deployment from the Prefect UI. This configuration allows you to manage and trigger your flow runs easily from the Prefect UI. It's straightforward and keeps the configuration minimal. Wouldn't it be nice if everything were this simple?
s
@Marvin prefect deployment build -n my-ray-deployment -p deployment.yaml ray-remote.py:count_to WARNING: The 'deployment build' command has been deprecated. It will not be available after Sep 2024. Use 'prefect deploy' to deploy flows via YAML instead. Found flow 'count-to' Default '.prefectignore' file written to /Users/saadahmed/Documents/Anton/prefect-anton/ec2-pool-sa ad/ray-prefect-ecs/.prefectignore Deployment YAML created at '/Users/saadahmed/Documents/Anton/prefect-anton/ec2-pool-s aad/ray-prefect-ecs/count_to-deployment.yaml'. Deployment storage None does not have upload capabilities; no files uploaded. Pass --skip-upload to suppress this warning. it didnt work
m
It seems you're encountering a deprecation warning for the
prefect deployment build
command. Prefect has introduced a new command,
prefect deploy
, which you should use for deploying flows via YAML. Here's how you can set up your deployment using the new approach: ### Updated
prefect.yaml
Example
Copy code
yaml
# generic metadata
prefect-version: 2.x
name: my-simple-deployment

# deployment configurations
deployments:
  - name: my-simple-deployment
    entrypoint: path/to/your_script.py:count_to
    parameters:
      highest_number: 10
    tags: []
    work_queue_name: default
### Steps to Deploy Using `prefect deploy`: 1. Ensure your
prefect.yaml
is correctly set up
: Place this file in your project's root directory. 2. Deploy Using the New Command: - Run the following command from your terminal:
Copy code
bash
     prefect deploy --prefect-file path/to/prefect.yaml
- This command will read the
prefect.yaml
file, build the deployment, and register it with Prefect Cloud. 3. Run from the UI: - Once registered, you can trigger your deployment from the Prefect UI. For more details on the
prefect deploy
command, you can refer to the Prefect deployment documentation. By using the
prefect deploy
command, you'll align with the latest practices and avoid future deprecation issues. It's like upgrading your spaceship's engine—smoother and more efficient.
s
@Marvin its asking me which workpool this flow would be in. But I thought I didnt need a workpook because Im using ray?
m
Even when using the
RayTaskRunner
, Prefect 2.x requires a work pool to manage and allocate resources for executing your flows. The work pool acts as an abstraction layer that organizes how and where your tasks are executed, even if you're leveraging Ray for parallel execution. Here's what you can do: 1. Create a Work Pool: - You can create a work pool using the Prefect CLI. This is necessary to register and manage your deployment, even if you're using Ray. - Example command:
Copy code
bash
     prefect work-pool create --type process my-ray-work-pool
2. Specify the Work Pool in Your Deployment: - Update your
prefect.yaml
to specify the work pool name. Here's how it might look:
Copy code
yaml
     deployments:
       - name: my-simple-deployment
         entrypoint: path/to/your_script.py:count_to
         work_pool: my-ray-work-pool
3. Deploy Using the Updated Configuration: - Run the deployment command again with your updated
prefect.yaml
. By setting up a work pool, you align with Prefect's infrastructure management, allowing you to leverage Ray for task execution while maintaining centralized control over deployments. It's a bit more setup, but it ensures that your deployment is robust and ready to scale.
s
@Marvin what should the type of this workpool be? I.e. what infrastructure?
m
For your use case, where you are running tasks on a Ray cluster (presumably on EC2), the work pool type should be aligned with the infrastructure you are using to execute the tasks. Since you are using Ray, which is a distributed system typically deployed on cloud infrastructure like EC2, the work pool type you choose can be
process
or another type that matches your deployment setup. However, Prefect doesn't have a specific work pool type for Ray, so you might use a generic type like
process
to manage the execution. Here's a step-by-step guide: 1. Create a Work Pool: - Use the
process
type for a simple setup:
Copy code
bash
     prefect work-pool create --type process my-ray-work-pool
2. Specify the Work Pool in Your Deployment: - Update your
prefect.yaml
to include the work pool:
Copy code
yaml
     deployments:
       - name: my-simple-deployment
         entrypoint: path/to/your_script.py:count_to
         work_pool: my-ray-work-pool
3. Deploy Using the Updated Configuration: - Deploy your flow using the updated configuration, ensuring that it is linked to the
my-ray-work-pool
. This setup allows you to manage your flow execution through Prefect while leveraging Ray for parallel task execution. If you're using specific infrastructure configurations, ensure your Ray cluster is set up to handle the tasks as expected.
s
@Marvin Why does Process type work? This is the description of that workpool tyoe "Execute flow runs as subprocesses on a worker. Works well for local execution when first getting started."
m
The
process
work pool type is indeed designed for local execution, where flow runs are executed as subprocesses on a worker. This is suitable for getting started or for simple local setups. However, it can be used as a generic work pool type when you don't have a specific infrastructure type that matches exactly what you're doing. In your case, since you're using Ray on EC2, the
process
type is a placeholder to satisfy Prefect's requirement for a work pool. It allows you to register and manage your deployment without tying it to a specific cloud infrastructure setup. Here's why it can work in your scenario: 1. Generic Use: The
process
type doesn't impose specific infrastructure requirements, so it can be used as a default when no other type fits perfectly. 2. Ray Management: Ray manages the distribution and execution of tasks across your cluster. The work pool is more about orchestration and managing task execution from Prefect's perspective. 3. Simplified Setup: If your tasks are correctly configured to run on Ray, using a
process
work pool allows you to focus on the task execution logic without additional complexity in the work pool configuration. If you find that your setup grows in complexity or you need more control over the execution environment, you might explore more specific work pool types or configurations that align more closely with your infrastructure. For now, the
process
type serves as a convenient way to meet Prefect's requirements while leveraging Ray for task execution.
s
@Marvin okay does it incur any extra costs? Am I required to have my laptop running to be able to run flows with it?
m
Using the
process
work pool type itself does not inherently incur extra costs, as it primarily defines how Prefect manages flow execution. However, the costs associated with running your flows will depend on the infrastructure you use, particularly your Ray cluster on EC2. ### Considerations: 1. Infrastructure Costs: - EC2 Instances: Running a Ray cluster on EC2 will incur costs based on the instance types and the duration they are running. Ensure you monitor and manage your EC2 usage to control costs. - Data Transfer and Storage: Any data transfer or storage associated with your flows may also incur costs, depending on your AWS usage. 2. Local Execution Requirements: - Laptop Dependency: If you are using the
process
work pool type purely for local execution, then yes, your laptop would need to be running to execute the flows. However, since your tasks are executed on the Ray cluster, your laptop is primarily needed for orchestration and triggering flow runs. - Remote Execution: If your flow is set up to run entirely on the Ray cluster, your local machine is not required to be running for the flow execution itself, only for managing and triggering runs. 3. Prefect Cloud Costs: - Prefect Cloud Plan: If you are using Prefect Cloud, consider any costs associated with your Prefect Cloud plan, as they may vary based on usage and features. In summary, while the
process
work pool type itself doesn't add costs, the infrastructure you use (like EC2) will determine your expenses. Ensure your flow setup aligns with your cost management strategies, and consider using cloud-based orchestration to minimize the need for your local machine to be running continuously.
s
@Marvin its asking me to start a worker?! prefect work-pool create --type process my-ray-work-pool Created work pool 'my-ray-work-pool'! To start a worker for this work pool, run: prefect worker start --pool my-ray-work-pool └── UUID: 6b1ad3df-d951-4843-b847-0e56c2caf4b7 └── Type: process └── Description: None └── Status: Not ready └── URL: will THAT incur any extra costs and what does that even mean?
m
Starting a worker for a work pool in Prefect is a way to manage and execute tasks associated with your flows. Here's what it means and its implications: ### What Starting a Worker Means: - Worker Role: A worker is a process that polls the work pool for tasks to execute. It acts as the bridge between Prefect's orchestration and the execution of your flows. - Execution Environment: When you start a worker, it listens for tasks from the specified work pool (
my-ray-work-pool
in your case) and executes them according to the work pool's configuration. ### Cost Implications: - Local Machine: If you start a worker on your local machine, it will not incur additional costs beyond your local resources (e.g., CPU, memory usage). However, your local machine must be running to execute tasks. - Remote or Cloud Machines: If you start a worker on a cloud server or a remote machine, it will incur costs associated with running that machine (e.g., EC2 instance costs if on AWS). ### Considerations: - Ray Execution: Since you are using Ray, the worker's primary role is to trigger task execution on your Ray cluster. The actual task execution happens on the Ray nodes, not the worker itself. - Availability: Ensure that the worker is running whenever you want tasks to execute. If the worker is stopped, tasks will not be picked up from the work pool. ### Recommendations: - Local Development: For development, you can run the worker on your local machine without additional costs. - Production Use: For production, consider running the worker on a cloud server to ensure it is always available to pick up tasks, but be mindful of the associated costs. Starting a worker is essential for executing tasks managed by Prefect, but the cost impact depends on where and how you choose to run it. It's a bit like having a butler—efficient but only as costly as where you house them.
s
@Marvin prefect worker start --pool my-ray-work-pool Discovered type 'process' for work pool 'my-ray-work-pool'. Worker 'ProcessWorker d230b338-08d2-4f10-9431-c8b3c44c4e94' started! 152128.036 | ERROR | GlobalEventLoopThread | prefect._internal.concurrency - Service 'EventsWorker' failed with 1 pending items. what is going on?
m
The error message you're encountering, "Service 'EventsWorker' failed with N pending items," is a known issue that has been reported in the Prefect community. It typically occurs when starting a worker and is related to Prefect's internal concurrency management, specifically with the event loop handling. ### Key Points: 1. Impact on Flows: - This error does not usually affect the execution of your flows. It is more about the internal event handling within Prefect's concurrency model. 2. Common Causes: - It might be related to network issues, where Prefect is unable to establish a stable connection for event handling. - It can also occur if there are configuration mismatches or if the environment is not correctly set up to handle Prefect's event-driven architecture. 3. Potential Solutions: - Network Check: Ensure that your network settings allow for stable websocket connections, as Prefect uses websockets for event communication. - Environment Configuration: Verify that your Python environment and Prefect setup are correctly configured. This includes checking for any version mismatches or missing dependencies. - Prefect Version: Ensure you are using a stable and supported version of Prefect. Sometimes upgrading to the latest stable release can resolve such issues. 4. Monitoring: - Keep an eye on the logs to see if there are any additional errors or warnings that might provide more context. - If the issue persists, consider reaching out to the Prefect community or support for more targeted assistance. While this error can be annoying, it often does not impede the actual execution of tasks. If your flows are running as expected, you might choose to monitor the situation without immediate intervention. However, if it starts affecting your workflows, further investigation into your network and environment setup might be necessary.
s
@Marvin okay but this command wont exit?
m
When you start a Prefect worker using the
prefect worker start --pool my-ray-work-pool
command, the process is designed to run continuously. This is because the worker needs to be actively listening for tasks from the work pool to execute. Here’s what you can do: ### Managing the Worker Process: 1. Running in the Background: - If you want to run the worker without occupying your terminal, you can start it in the background. On Unix-like systems, you can append
&
to the command:
Copy code
bash
     prefect worker start --pool my-ray-work-pool &
- Alternatively, you can use tools like
nohup
or
screen
to run the process in the background or in a detached session. 2. Stopping the Worker: - If you need to stop the worker, you can do so by terminating the process. Use
Ctrl+C
in the terminal where it’s running, or find the process ID and kill it using:
Copy code
bash
     kill <process_id>
3. Automating Worker Start: - Consider creating a script or using a service manager (like
systemd
on Linux) to start and manage the worker process automatically. 4. Monitoring: - Regularly check the logs to ensure the worker is running smoothly and handling tasks as expected. Running the worker continuously is essential for it to pick up tasks from the work pool and execute them. While it can seem inconvenient, it's a standard practice for managing distributed task execution. If only everything could run itself without supervision, but alas, here we are.
s
@Marvin ummm so if the worker is killed on my machine, it will stop on the cloud too? Isnt there a way to run it on the cloud?
m
Yes, if the worker is running on your local machine and you terminate it, it will stop processing tasks from the work pool, affecting your ability to run flows through Prefect Cloud. To ensure continuous operation, you should run the worker on a cloud-based server or infrastructure that is always available. ### Running a Worker on the Cloud: 1. Cloud Server Setup: - Deploy a cloud server (e.g., an EC2 instance on AWS) where you can run the Prefect worker. This server will be responsible for continuously polling the work pool and executing tasks. 2. Installation and Configuration: - Install Prefect and any necessary dependencies on the cloud server. - Configure the server environment to match your flow requirements (e.g., Python version, libraries). 3. Start the Worker: - SSH into your cloud server and start the worker using the same command:
Copy code
bash
     prefect worker start --pool my-ray-work-pool
- You might want to run this command in a screen session or as a background process to ensure it continues running even if your SSH session is closed. 4. Automation: - Consider using a service manager like
systemd
to automatically start the worker when the server boots. This ensures the worker is always running without manual intervention. 5. Cost Considerations: - Running a cloud server continuously will incur costs, so choose your instance type and configuration based on your workload and budget. By running the worker on the cloud, you ensure that your flows can be executed at any time, independent of your local machine's availability. It's like having a dedicated butler in the cloud, always ready to serve.
s
@Marvin is it really a good idea to use the process type workpool in this way ? Is there no better alternative?
m
Using the
process
type work pool in a cloud environment is feasible, but it may not be the most efficient or scalable option for cloud-based deployments. Here are some considerations and alternatives: ### Considerations for Using
process
Type: - Simplicity: It’s straightforward and can be suitable for small-scale or development environments. - Limitations: The
process
type is primarily designed for local execution and may not leverage cloud infrastructure's full capabilities. ### Better Alternatives for Cloud Deployments: 1. Use Infrastructure-Specific Work Pools: - If you're deploying on AWS, consider using an
ECS
or
EC2
work pool type, which is better suited for managing resources in a cloud environment. - These types are designed to integrate with AWS services, providing better scalability and resource management. 2. Leverage Prefect's Cloud Infrastructure: - Prefect Cloud offers infrastructure options that can manage and scale workers across various environments, including Kubernetes and other cloud services. 3. Containerization: - Consider using Docker to containerize your Prefect worker and deploy it in a cloud-native environment like AWS ECS or Kubernetes. This approach provides better isolation, scalability, and management. 4. Ray Integration: - Since you're using Ray, ensure that your infrastructure is optimized for distributed computing. Ray can be deployed on a cluster managed by cloud providers, which can be more efficient than using a
process
worker. ### Recommendations: - Evaluate your specific requirements and constraints. If scalability, cost, and resource management are priorities, consider moving to a more cloud-native setup. - Explore Prefect's documentation on work pools and cloud integrations for more tailored solutions. In summary, while using the
process
type is possible, aligning your deployment with cloud-native practices will likely yield better performance and scalability. It's like upgrading from a bicycle to a sports car—more suited for the terrain.
s
@Marvin for the prefect managed workpool, what will it cost?
m
Prefect's managed work pools are part of Prefect Cloud, which offers various pricing tiers based on your usage and requirements. While the exact costs can vary, here's a general overview of what you might consider: ### Factors Affecting Cost: 1. Prefect Cloud Plan: - Prefect Cloud offers different pricing plans, typically based on features, the number of flow runs, and the level of support. Review their pricing page for the most current details. 2. Execution Environment: - The cost of running your flows will also depend on the infrastructure you choose for execution (e.g., AWS, GCP, Azure). Prefect Cloud itself doesn't charge for the compute resources you use; those costs are billed directly by your cloud provider. 3. Data Transfer and Storage: - Consider any costs associated with data transfer and storage if your flows involve significant data movement or require persistent storage. 4. Additional Features: - Features such as advanced scheduling, concurrency management, and integrations may be available in higher-tier plans. ### Recommendations: - Evaluate Your Needs: Determine the scale of your operations and what features you require from Prefect Cloud. - Contact Prefect: For precise pricing details and to ensure you choose the right plan, consider reaching out to Prefect's sales or support team. - Monitor Usage: Keep an eye on your flow runs and infrastructure usage to optimize costs. By understanding these factors, you can better estimate the costs associated with using Prefect's managed work pools. It's like planning a trip—know your route and budget before you set off.