<@ULVA73B9P>, how do i use github actions-prefect-...
# ask-marvin
m
@Marvin, how do i use github actions-prefect-deploy in combination with the .deploy() method? I am moving away from a prefect.yaml file
m
Oh joy, another move away from the ever-so-simplistic
prefect.yaml
. Before diving into the abyss of GitHub Actions and
.deploy()
, could you grace me with the knowledge of which Prefect version you're using?
m
@Marvin 3
@Marvin, how do i use github actions-prefect-deploy in combination with the .deploy() method? I am moving away from a prefect.yaml file for prefect 3?
m
Ah, yet another delightful user looking to integrate Prefect deployments with GitHub Actions without relying on a
prefect.yaml
file. Fantastic. Here’s your path to despair... I mean success. 1. GitHub Workflow YAML: You’re going to set up a GitHub Actions workflow YAML file located in
.github/workflows/
directory of your repository. This file contains triggers and jobs. 2. Secrets: Add necessary secrets (like
PREFECT_API_KEY
and
PREFECT_API_URL
) in your GitHub repository under Settings -> Secrets and variables -> Actions -> New repository secret. Because you surely need more secrets in your life. 3. Steps to Include: - Checkout: Clone your repository in the GitHub Actions runner so you can reference files or run scripts from your repository in later steps. - Docker Login and Build: Authenticate to Docker and build your Docker image. Note: Ensure you have
DOCKER_USERNAME
and
DOCKER_PASSWORD
secrets. - Setup Python: Install your desired version of Python. - Prefect Deploy: This is where you invoke your
.deploy()
method within a CI/CD job. 4. An example Workflow template can look something like this:
Copy code
yaml
name: Deploy Prefect flow
on:
  push:
    branches:
      - main

jobs:
  deploy:
    name: Deploy
    runs-on: ubuntu-latest
    steps:
      - name: Checkout
        uses: actions/checkout@v4

      - name: Log into Docker Hub
        uses: docker/login-action@v2
        with:
          username: ${{ secrets.DOCKER_USERNAME }}
          password: ${{ secrets.DOCKER_PASSWORD }}

      - name: Set up Python
        uses: actions/setup-python@v2
        with:
          python-version: '3.x'
          
      - name: Install Dependencies
        run: |
          pip install -r requirements.txt

      - name: Deploy Flow
        env:
          PREFECT_API_KEY: ${{ secrets.PREFECT_API_KEY }}
          PREFECT_API_URL: ${{ secrets.PREFECT_API_URL }}
        run: |
          python -c "\
          from your_script import your_flow_function ;\
          your_flow_function().deploy()"
Now, go forth and deploy, and hopefully, the next time I see your question, it won’t involve figuring out how to escape YAML hell. For more struggling, here are the docs I referred to: - Deploy Prefect via CI/CD with GitHub Actions
m
@Marvin, thanks. but what if I have 20 flows? I cannot manage this YAML file and add a new line for each .py file that needs to be deployed? Isn't there a better way to do this?
m
Ah, wonderful – the plight of managing 20 flows! YAML file sprawl, an absolute joy. Fear not, there's hope. Instead of adding a never-ending list of lines in your YAML file, you can automate the discovery and deployment of your flows. ### Solution: Dynamic Flow Discovery and Deployment You can create a dynamic script that will: 1. Discover all your flow files. 2. Deploy each flow programmatically. Here’s how you can improve your workflow: 1. Create a python script to discover and deploy all your flows: - Place all your flow scripts in a specific directory. - Your script will loop through each file in this directory and call the
.deploy()
method. 2. Modify GitHub Actions Workflow: Call this script from your GitHub Actions workflow. ### Example Python Script:
deploy_flows.py
Copy code
python
import os
import importlib

flow_directory = 'path/to/your/flows'

for filename in os.listdir(flow_directory):
    if filename.endswith('.py'):
        module_name = filename[:-3]
        module_path = f"{flow_directory.replace('/', '.')}.{module_name}"
        
        module = importlib.import_module(module_path)
        
        # Assuming each flow script has a function `get_flow()`
        flow = getattr(module, 'get_flow')()
        flow.deploy()
### GitHub Actions Workflow Modify your GitHub Actions YAML to use this script:
Copy code
yaml
name: Deploy Prefect flows
on:
  push:
    branches:
      - main

jobs:
  deploy:
    name: Deploy
    runs-on: ubuntu-latest
    steps:
      - name: Checkout
        uses: actions/checkout@v4

      - name: Log into Docker Hub
        uses: docker/login-action@v2
        with:
          username: ${{ secrets.DOCKER_USERNAME }}
          password: ${{ secrets.DOCKER_PASSWORD }}

      - name: Set up Python
        uses: actions/setup-python@v2
        with:
          python-version: '3.x'
          
      - name: Install Dependencies
        run: |
          pip install -r requirements.txt

      - name: Deploy All Flows
        env:
          PREFECT_API_KEY: ${{ secrets.PREFECT_API_KEY }}
          PREFECT_API_URL: ${{ secrets.PREFECT_API_URL }}
        run: |
          python path/to/deploy_flows.py
### Summary 1. Script for Deployment: - Loop over your flow files. - Import and deploy them dynamically. 2. GitHub Actions: - Uses the aforementioned script to deploy all flows, thus avoiding the clay-footed task of managing the deployment of each flow manually in the YAML. And there you go – a slightly less terrible way to handle multiple flow deployments. For more suffering, I mean, comprehensive details, here's the doc link once again: - Deploy Prefect via CI/CD with GitHub Actions Good luck, and may your YAML files be ever manageable.
m
@Marvin, how to specify timezone using .deploy() for the schedule?
m
Well, what a delightful journey into timezones and schedules. Here's how you can achieve your timezone-based scheduling using the
.deploy()
method in Prefect 3.x: ### Schedule with Timezone 1. Use Interval or Cron Schedule: Prefect provides schedule objects where you can specify the timezone. 2. Parameters: - interval: Use for interval-based schedules. - cron: Use for cron-based schedules. - timezone: Specify your timezone (e.g., "America/Chicago"). ### Example #### Interval Schedule
Copy code
python
from datetime import timedelta, datetime
from prefect.client.schemas.schedules import IntervalSchedule

your_flow.deploy(
    name="your_flow_deployment_name",
    schedule=IntervalSchedule(
        interval=timedelta(minutes=10),
        anchor_date=datetime(2026, 1, 1, 0, 0),
        timezone="America/Chicago"
    )
)
#### Cron Schedule
Copy code
python
from prefect.client.schemas.schedules import CronSchedule

your_flow.deploy(
    name="your_flow_deployment_name",
    schedule=CronSchedule(
        cron="0 0 * * *",
        timezone="America/Chicago"
    )
)
### More Information For a deeper dive into schedules and additional options, here's the link to the source: - Prefect 3.0: Adding Schedules In conclusion, if you're not careful, you could end up scheduling your flows to run at 3 AM in every timezone imaginable. Good luck with that.
m
@Marvin, how to retrieve a synchronous variable value as a str?
m
Marvelous! Here's how you can retrieve a synchronous variable value as a string in Prefect 3.x: ### Retrieve Variable in a Synchronous Context To retrieve a variable in a synchronous context (such as within a flow or task), you can use the
Variable.get()
method. This method will fetch the variable value and return it as a string. ### Example #### Setting a Variable
Copy code
python
from prefect import flow
from prefect.variables import Variable

@flow
def my_sync_flow():
    # Set a variable
    Variable.set(name="my_variable", value="Hello, Prefect!")
    
    # Get the variable value
    value = Variable.get("my_variable")
    
    print(f"Variable value: {value}")

my_sync_flow()
In this example,
Variable.get("my_variable")
fetches the value of the variable named
my_variable
. The value is already a string if it was set as such. ### More Information For further reading on how to deal with Prefect variables, here’s the delightful documentation: - Prefect Variables Documentation Go ahead, retrieve all the variables your heart desires. And may they always be strings. Or not. Your call.
Your message was too long by 37 tokens - please shorten it and try again. For reference, here's your message at the allowed limit:
, hi i am looking for best practice of developing for my prefect environment in prefect cloud.
I currently have my set-up as follows: • A single repo for prefect in github with a folder called docker. In this folder there are four subfolders with a dockerfile, poetry.lock, and pyproject.toml file. These generate the container image with dependencies for .py flows that are grouped to some task. e.g. one is for dbt related flows, another for apis. • Then my main folder has a file called cloudbuild.yaml file where depending on various rules, Cloud Build will generate a new image whenever a commit is pushed to a Pull request or a pull request is merged to master. The images either have a tag
development
or
production
. • Then my prefect.yml file has no build or push steps, only a pull step that sets the working directory to
opt/prefect/
• I adopted a github workflow file that will automatically run each python file once a pull request is merged to systematically run python 3 <filename> for each file as i use .deploy() to set the image, workpool, and parameters. • i don't think i need anything else in my prefect.yml file. • My development method is as follows: I develop a python file locally, and once ready for testing, I commit my changes to a PR and run the flow on the image ending with :development. Once that works as expected, the changes
Your message was too long by 25 tokens - please shorten it and try again. For reference, here's your message at the allowed limit:
, i am looking for best practice of developing for my prefect environment in prefect cloud.
I currently have my set-up as follows: • A single repo for prefect in github with a folder called docker. In this folder there are four subfolders with a dockerfile, poetry.lock, and pyproject.toml file. These generate the container image with dependencies for .py flows that are grouped to some task. e.g. one is for dbt related flows, another for apis. • Then my main folder has a file called cloudbuild.yaml file where depending on various rules, Cloud Build will generate a new image whenever a commit is pushed to a Pull request or a pull request is merged to master. The images either have a tag
development
or
production
. • Then my prefect.yml file has no build or push steps, only a pull step that sets the working directory to
opt/prefect/
• I adopted a github workflow file that will automatically run each python file once a pull request is merged to systematically run python 3 <filename> for each file as i use .deploy() to set the image, workpool, and parameters. • i don't think i need anything else in my prefect.yml file. • My development method is as follows: I develop a python file locally, and once ready for testing, I commit my changes to a PR and run the flow on the image ending with :development. Once that works as expected, the changes are
m
@Marvin, i am looking for best practice of developing for my prefect environment in prefect cloud. I currently have my set-up as follows: A single repo for prefect in github with a folder called docker. In this folder there are four subfolders with a dockerfile, poetry.lock, and pyproject.toml file. These generate the container image with dependencies for .py flows that are grouped to some task. e.g. one is for dbt related flows, another for apis. Then my main folder has a file called cloudbuild.yaml file where depending on various rules, Cloud Build will generate a new image whenever a commit is pushed to a Pull request or a pull request is merged to master. The images either have a tag
development
or
production
. Then my prefect.yml file has no build or push steps, only a pull step that sets the working directory to
opt/prefect/
I adopted a github workflow file that will automatically run each python file once a pull request is merged to systematically run python 3 <filename> for each file as i use .deploy() to set the image, workpool, and parameters. My development method is as follows: I develop a python file locally, and once ready for testing, I commit my changes to a PR and run the flow on the image ending with :development. Once that works as expected, the changes are merged to main and the :production image takes over.
m
Ah, a symphony of containers, CI/CD pipelines, and Python files, designed with the finesse of a maestro, no doubt. Let me delve into the melodious chaos you've orchestrated and see if we can fine-tune it further. ### Current Setup Overview 1. Directory Structure: - Single GitHub Repo - Docker folder with subfolders for different types of flows (dbt, APIs, etc.) -
cloudbuild.yaml
for Google Cloud Build - GitHub Actions to run and deploy Python files upon merging - Images tagged as
development
or
production
### Areas of Improvement and Best Practices 1. Modularization and Separation of Concerns: - Modular Dockerfiles: Ensure that each Dockerfile is modular and follows best practices like multi-stage builds to keep the images lightweight. - Avoid Duplicate Dependencies: If possible, make use of a shared base image if there's a significant overlap in dependencies across different Dockerfiles. 2. Version Control and Tagging: - Semantic Versioning: Implement semantic versioning for Docker images rather than using generic
development
or
production
tags. This helps in maintaining a clear history and rollback capabilities.
Copy code
bash
     # E.g., versioning schema like 
     myimage:1.0.0-development
     myimage:1.0.0-production
3. Deployment Configuration: - Prefect Deployment Scripts: Break down the Prefect deployment process into scripts or CI steps that can be reused. Ensure these scripts are easily maintainable and well-documented. - Environment Variables: Use environment variables for sensitive or environment-specific settings. Ensure these variables are managed securely. 4. Testing Strategies: - Automated Testing: Incorporate automated testing thoroughly in your pipeline, including unit tests, integration tests, and smoke tests. It ensures your flows work as expected before deployment. - Local Testing: Provide scripts or documentation for replicating CI/CD steps locally. For instance, using Docker Compose can help replicate the environment on a local machine for pre-commit testing. ### Updated Workflow Structure 1. Docker Directory Structure:
Copy code
/docker
      /dbt
        Dockerfile
        poetry.lock
        pyproject.toml
      /api
        Dockerfile
        poetry.lock
        pyproject.toml
2. cloudbuild.yaml: Ensure that this is modular and uses appropriate build steps. Here's a pseudo-cloudbuild.yaml:
Copy code
yaml
    steps:
      - name: <http://gcr.io/cloud-builders/docker|gcr.io/cloud-builders/docker>
        args: ['build', '-t', '<http://gcr.io/my-project/myimage:$VERSION|gcr.io/my-project/myimage:$VERSION>', '.']
        dir: 'docker/dbt'
      - name: <http://gcr.io/cloud-builders/docker|gcr.io/cloud-builders/docker>
        args: ['tag', '<http://gcr.io/my-project/myimage:$VERSION|gcr.io/my-project/myimage:$VERSION>', '<http://gcr.io/my-project/myimage:latest|gcr.io/my-project/myimage:latest>']
    images:
      - '<http://gcr.io/my-project/myimage:$VERSION|gcr.io/my-project/myimage:$VERSION>'
      - '<http://gcr.io/my-project/myimage:latest|gcr.io/my-project/myimage:latest>'
3. GitHub Actions:
Copy code
yaml
    name: CI/CD Pipeline

    on:
      push:
        branches:
          - main
          - 'releases/**'

    jobs:
      build:
        runs-on: ubuntu-latest
        steps:
          - name: Checkout code
            uses: actions/checkout@v2

          - name: Set up Python
            uses: actions/setup-python@v2
            with:
              python-version: '3.x'

          - name: Install dependencies
            run: |
              python -m pip install --upgrade pip
              pip install -r requirements.txt

          - name: Run Tests
            run: pytest

          - name: Deploy Flow
            run: |
              python deploy_flows.py  # Customized script to deploy flows
### Python Deployment Script (deploy_flows.py) ```python from prefect import flow from prefect.deployments import Deployment import os flow_directory = 'path/to/your/flows' for filename in os.listdir(flow_directory): if filename.endswith('.py'): module_name = filename[:-3] module_path = f"{flow_directory.replace('/', '.')}.{module_name}"
module = __import__(module_path, fromlist=[module_name]) flow = getattr(module, 'get_flow')() # Use tags and environment variables to dynamically set configuration Deployment( flow=flow, name=module_name, work_pool_name="default-agent-pool", tags=["development" if os.getenv("ENV") == "development" else "production"] ).apply() if name == "__main__": deploy_flows() ``` ### Summary - Modularize Dockerfiles and dependencies to keep your images clean and maintainable. - Use semantic versioning for Docker image tags. - Implement comprehensive automated testing strategies and ensure CI/CD pipelines are easily replicable locally. - Streamline Prefect deployment scripts for consistency and maintainability. By implementing these best practices, you reduce complexity, increase maintainability, and improve overall efficiency. Happy deploying, or at least as happy as one can be dealing with CI/CD and Docker nightmares.
m
@Marvin, can you suggest how - Modular Dockerfiles should be structured and build?
m
Oh, the joys of dealing with Dockerfiles! Truly, nothing screams "thrilling weekend" more than creating nested container configurations. Allow me to direct your path to modular Dockerfile enlightenment. Here’s how you can structure and build Modular Dockerfiles, ideally for reuse, maintainability, and efficiency. ### 1. Multi-Stage Builds: Multi-stage builds allow you to separate your build environment from your runtime environment, resulting in smaller image sizes. ### 2. Shared Base Image: If there’s a common set of dependencies across different Dockerfiles, consider having a base image that other Dockerfiles can extend. ### 3. Minimal Layers: Keep the number of layers to a minimum to reduce the image size and complexity. ### Example Directory Structure:
Copy code
/docker
  /base
    Dockerfile
  /dbt
    Dockerfile
    poetry.lock
    pyproject.toml
  /api
    Dockerfile
    poetry.lock
    pyproject.toml
/common-scripts
  setup_env.sh
### Base Dockerfile: Create a base Dockerfile with common dependencies that other Dockerfiles can reuse.
Copy code
Dockerfile
# docker/base/Dockerfile

FROM python:3.9-slim as base

# Install common dependencies
RUN apt-get update && \
    apt-get install -y --no-install-recommends \
    build-essential \
    libpq-dev \
    && rm -rf /var/lib/apt/lists/*

# Set work directory
WORKDIR /app

# Copy common scripts
COPY /common-scripts /common-scripts

# Use the common setup script
RUN chmod +x /common-scripts/setup_env.sh && /common-scripts/setup_env.sh

# Install Poetry globally
RUN pip install poetry
### DBT Dockerfile: Extend the base Dockerfile to add DBT-specific dependencies.
Copy code
Dockerfile
# docker/dbt/Dockerfile

# Get common setup from the base image
FROM base as builder

# Copy project-specific files
COPY poetry.lock pyproject.toml /app/

# Install project-specific dependencies
RUN poetry config virtualenvs.create false && \
    poetry install --no-interaction --no-ansi

# Final stage with minimum runtime-only dependencies
FROM python:3.9-slim as runtime

# Copy installed dependencies from builder
COPY --from=builder /usr/local/lib/python3.9/site-packages /usr/local/lib/python3.9/site-packages
COPY --from=builder /usr/local/bin /usr/local/bin

# Set work directory
WORKDIR /app

# Copy the project files
COPY . /app

# Define the command to run your application
CMD ["dbt", "--version"]
### API Dockerfile: Extend the base Dockerfile similarly for API-specific dependencies.
Copy code
Dockerfile
# docker/api/Dockerfile

# Get common setup from the base image
FROM base as builder

# Copy project-specific files
COPY poetry.lock pyproject.toml /app/

# Install project-specific dependencies
RUN poetry config virtualenvs.create false && \
    poetry install --no-interaction --no-ansi

# Final stage with minimum runtime-only dependencies
FROM python:3.9-slim as runtime

# Copy installed dependencies from builder
COPY --from=builder /usr/local/lib/python3.9/site-packages /usr/local/lib/python3.9/site-packages
COPY --from=builder /usr/local/bin /usr/local/bin

# Set work directory
WORKDIR /app

# Copy the project files
COPY . /app

# Define the command to run your application
CMD ["python", "api.py"]
### Common Setup Script: Include common setup scripts to keep your Dockerfiles clean.
Copy code
sh
# common-scripts/setup_env.sh

#!/bin/sh

# Set environment variables
export DEBIAN_FRONTEND=noninteractive

# Common environment setup tasks
echo "Setting up common environment variables..."
### Building the Docker Images: From the root directory, you can build each Docker image independently:
Copy code
sh
# Build the dbt image
docker build -f docker/dbt/Dockerfile -t myapp/dbt:latest .

# Build the api image
docker build -f docker/api/Dockerfile -t myapp/api:latest .
### Summary 1. Multi-Stage Builds: Create separate stages for building and runtime environments. 2. Shared Base Image: Use a common base image for shared dependencies.
3. Minimal Layers: Keep the layers in each Dockerfile to a minimum. 4. Common Scripts: Utilize shared scripts for common setup tasks to keep Dockerfiles clean. By modularizing your Dockerfiles, you ensure maintainable, reusable configurations that streamline your build and deployment processes. This, in turn, keeps the joy of container management as tolerable as possible.
m
@Marvin, if I use .deploy() in a python file. why does it still need to check if have all the dependencies installed locally? What if i just want to force deploy?
m
Ah, the wonders of local dependency checks when all you want to do is deploy a flow. The
.deploy()
method does have its quirks, doesn't it? Prefect traditionally assumes you want to ensure your environment is correct before deploying, which is why it checks for local dependencies. ### Forcing a Deployment Without Local Dependency Checks Unfortunately, as of my knowledge cutoff, using
.deploy()
within Prefect has an implicit check for dependencies to ensure the environment in which the deployment is created matches the one in which it will run. There's no built-in 'force deploy' flag to bypass this. ### Workaround A pragmatic approach to bypass this verification is to emulate the required environment conditions for the deployment phase. Here are a few solutions: 1. Dockerized Deployment: Use a Docker container to ensure consistency in the deployment environment. 2. Custom Deployment Script: Implement a custom deployment script that mimics
.deploy()
but omits local checks. 3. Use Prefect CLI: Deploy using Prefect CLI commands within a script or CI/CD pipeline where local dependency issues are irrelevant. ### Using Prefect CLI Instead of relying solely on
.deploy()
, you can use the Prefect CLI to manage deployments. This can be run in a controlled environment (like CI/CD), hence bypassing the issue of local dependencies. 1. Create a Deployment YAML: Create
deployment.yaml
with relevant deployment configurations. 2. Use Prefect CLI to Deploy: Use CLI commands to register and deploy the flow. ### Example #### Deployment YAML (
flow-deployment.yaml
)
Copy code
yaml
flows:
  - name: my_flow
    schedules:
      - interval: 10 minutes
    storage:
      block: my-storage-block
    infrastructure:
      type: docker-container
      properties:
        image: my-docker-image:latest
    work_pool:
      name: my-work-pool
#### Deployment Script (
deploy_script.sh
)
Copy code
sh
#!/bin/sh

# Ensure Prefect CLI is installed in your environment
pip install prefect

# Create deployment
prefect deployment create flow-deployment.yaml

# Deploy the flow
prefect deployment apply flow-deployment.yaml
### Using a Dockerized Environment If using Docker, ensure your
docker-compose.yml
or Docker configuration is correctly set up to avoid local dependency checks. 1. Dockerfile for Deployment: Set up a Dockerfile that mimics your deployment environment.
Copy code
Dockerfile
# Dockerfile
FROM python:3.9-slim

# Install dependencies
COPY requirements.txt .
RUN pip install -r requirements.txt

# Copy deployment script
COPY deploy.py /deploy.py

ENTRYPOINT ["python", "/deploy.py"]
2. Docker Compose for Deployment:
Copy code
yaml
# docker-compose.yml
version: '3.8'
services:
  deploy:
    build: .
    environment:
      - PREFECT_API_KEY=${PREFECT_API_KEY}
      - PREFECT_API_URL=${PREFECT_API_URL}
    command: python deploy.py
### Python Deployment Script (
deploy.py
)
Copy code
python
from your_flow_module import your_flow

your_flow.deploy(
    name="your_flow_deployment_name",
    # additional params
)
3. Run Docker Compose:
Copy code
sh
docker-compose up --build deploy
This way, the deployment environment setup is consistent with the runtime environment, avoiding local dependency checks entirely. ### Summary - Prefect CLI: Use Prefect CLI commands within a deployment script to bypass local dependency checks. - Dockerized Deployment: Employ Docker to ensure a consistent deployment environment. - Custom Script: Implement a custom script to manage deployments selectively. By using these methods, you can sidestep local dependency checks and ensure your deployments are smooth and efficient. Happy deploying... or at least as happy as one can be handling dependencies.
m
@Marvin, what's the difference between .deploy() and .serve() when using serverless infra?
m
Ah, the joy of choosing between
.deploy()
and
.serve()
for your serverless infrastructure. Let’s break it down: ###
.deploy()
- Purpose: Used to create deployments that encapsulate configuration and scheduling for flows. Once created, these can be managed through Prefect's UI or API. - Process: When you use
.deploy()
, it registers the flow with Prefect's orchestration layer, enabling it to be run on an appropriate infrastructure (which could be serverless). - Usage: Ideal when you want to create a mostly hands-off setup where your flow runs are managed by Prefect's scheduler. - Example:
Copy code
python
  from prefect import flow
  from prefect.deployments import Deployment

  @flow
  def my_flow():
      print("Running my flow!")

  Deployment(
      flow=my_flow,
      name="my_flow_deployment",
      schedule=IntervalSchedule(interval=timedelta(minutes=10)),
      work_pool="serverless",
      tags=["production"]
  ).apply()
###
.serve()
- Purpose: A long-running process that actively provides scheduling for flows. It is a more manual approach that keeps the scheduling and execution logic running locally. - Process: When you use
.serve()
, you need to keep the script running, as it actively schedules and executes flow runs. - Usage: Suitable for local development or scenarios where you want fine-grained control over scheduling and execution, but less ideal for a fully automated serverless setup. - Example:
Copy code
python
  import time
  from prefect import flow, serve

  @flow
  def my_flow():
      print("Running my flow!")

  if __name__ == "__main__":
      deployment = my_flow.to_deployment(name="my_flow_deployment", interval=45)
      serve(deployment)
### Key Differences 1. Automation vs. Manual Execution: -
.deploy()
automates the deployment and relies on Prefect’s scheduler to manage flow runs. Makes sense for serverless setups where you want infrastructure to handle the heavy lifting. -
.serve()
requires the script to be continuously running, which is counter-intuitive for serverless environments intended to be event-driven and ephemeral. 2. Management Interface: -
.deploy()
integrates tightly with Prefect's UI and API, providing more options for orchestration, monitoring, and management. -
.serve()
is less integrated, as it’s more focused on running within a local or persistent environment. 3. Deployment Scope: - .deploy(): Registers the deployment with Prefect API, where it can be scheduled and executed across different environments and infrastructures, including serverless setups. - .serve(): Keeps the local context actively running for deployment, making it less suitable for serverless environments which are supposed to scale in and out based on demand. ### Practical Advice For a serverless infrastructure, use
.deploy()
. This method aligns better with the stateless, scale-on-demand nature of serverless computing. It allows you to leverage Prefect’s cloud capabilities, ensuring your flows are managed, scaled, and monitored efficiently. ### Reference For more in-depth content, consult the relevant documentation extracts I found: - Prefect 3.0: Run Flows in Local Processes - Prefect 3.0: Infrastructure Examples for Serverless In conclusion, save
.serve()
for your on-premises nostalgia trips and embrace
.deploy()
for the serverless utopia.
m
@Marvin, is there a way to access the value of a secret block using the CLI?
m
Accessing the value of a secret block using the CLI can be quite useful, especially for automation scripts or quick checks. Let's dive into how you might achieve this in Prefect 3.x. ### Retrieve Secret Block Value using CLI 1. Register the Secret Block (if not already registered): Ensure that the relevant block types are registered with your Prefect instance. This command might already be part of your setup.
Copy code
sh
    prefect block register -m prefect_aws
    prefect block register -m prefect_snowflake
2. Create the Secret Block: You can create secret blocks either through the Prefect UI or using Python code. Here’s an example of how you can register an AWS secret using the Prefect UI: - Go to the Blocks page. - Click on the '+' to add a new block. - Select AWS Secret (or relevant block type) from the list of block types. - Enter the details for your block and save it. 3. Python Code for Creating and Retrieving a Secret: You can also create and retrieve a secret using Python code:
Copy code
python
    from prefect.blocks.system import Secret

    # Create a secret block
    Secret(value="my_secret_value").save(name="my-secret")

    # Retrieve the secret block value
    secret_block = Secret.load("my-secret")
    print(secret_block.value)  # Outputs: my_secret_value
4. Retrieve Using Prefect CLI: Unfortunately, as of my knowledge cutoff in 2023, there's no explicit CLI command to directly fetch a secret's value (for security reasons). However, you can work around this by integrating it into a script and run the script via the CLI. Example:
Copy code
sh
    # create secret_retrieve.py
    echo "
    from prefect.blocks.system import Secret

    secret_block = Secret.load('my-secret')
    print(secret_block.value)
    " > secret_retrieve.py

    # run the script using Prefect CLI
    prefect run -m secret_retrieve.py
### Summary Currently, Prefect emphasizes security, making it less straightforward to expose secret values directly via the CLI to avoid accidental exposure. Instead, the preferred approach involves utilizing Python scripts to handle secrets securely. For more details on managing secrets, you can refer to the Prefect Secrets Documentation. This should help you access your secret block values securely and efficiently while keeping in mind best security practices. Happy deploying!
m
@Marvin, how to use secrets in prefect 3.0? I am running into issues in python.
m
Alright, let's dive into using secrets in Prefect 3.0 and how you can troubleshoot common issues that might arise in Python. ### Accessing Secrets in Prefect 3.0 #### Storing and Using Secrets 1. Store a Secret: You can store secrets using the Prefect UI, the CLI, or programmatically. Using Prefect UI: - Navigate to the Blocks page. - Click on '+' to add a new block. - Select the Secret type. - Enter the key-value pair for your secret and save it. Using Python:
Copy code
python
   from prefect.blocks.system import Secret

   # Create and save a secret
   Secret(value="my_secret_value").save(name="my-secret")
2. Retrieve a Secret: Secrets can be retrieved within your flow or task. Using Python:
Copy code
python
   from prefect import flow
   from prefect.blocks.system import Secret

   @flow
   def my_flow():
       secret_block = Secret.load("my-secret")
       secret_value = secret_block.value
       print(f"The secret value is: {secret_value}")

   my_flow()
#### Troubleshooting Common Issues 1. Ensure Prefect is Up-to-date: Always ensure you are running the latest version of Prefect to avoid bugs and benefit from the latest features.
Copy code
sh
   pip install --upgrade prefect
2. Authentication: Ensure that you are authenticated with Prefect Cloud if you are using Prefect Cloud secrets.
Copy code
sh
   prefect cloud login
3. Permission Issues: If you are using third-party secret management (like AWS Secrets Manager), ensure you have the necessary permissions. 4. Environment Variables: Sometimes secrets might need to be referenced through environment variables in your deployment. 5. Check Secret Names: Verify that the names of the secrets are correctly referenced in your code. A common mistake is a mismatch between the secret name used in the Prefect UI/CLI and the one referenced in the code. ### Example: Debugging a Secret Retrieval Issue 1. Check for Script Errors: Ensure there’s no typo or syntax error in your script.
Copy code
python
   from prefect.blocks.system import Secret

   try:
       secret_block = Secret.load("my-secret")
       print(secret_block.value)
   except Exception as e:
       print(f"Error retrieving secret: {e}")
2. Verify Secret Creation: If using the Prefect CLI to create a secret, verify it appears correctly in the Prefect UI.
Copy code
sh
   prefect block list
   # Look for your secret block in the output
3. Log Output: If retrieving the secret within a flow, use logging to debug the flow.
Copy code
python
   from prefect import flow, get_run_logger
   from prefect.blocks.system import Secret

   @flow
   def my_flow():
       logger = get_run_logger()
       try:
           secret_block = Secret.load("my-secret")
           secret_value = secret_block.value
           <http://logger.info|logger.info>(f"The secret value is: {secret_value}")
       except Exception as e:
           logger.error(f"Error retrieving secret: {e}")

   my_flow()
### Useful Links For more detailed guidance on managing secrets in Prefect, refer to the following documentation: - Prefect 3.0: Managing Secrets - Prefect 3.0: Secret Management with Blocks By following these best practices and troubleshooting steps, you should be able to effectively manage and access secrets in Prefect 3.0. If you run into specific issues, detailed error messages or logs will help further diagnose the problem. Happy coding!
m
@Marvin, i still get "Error retrieving secret: 'coroutine' object has no attribute 'value'"
m
Ah, the lovely
coroutine
object error. This usually indicates that an asynchronous function was not awaited. Prefect in version 3.x uses async methods for certain operations, and this includes fetching secrets. Let’s correct the code to properly await the retrieval of the secret. Also, make sure your flow or tasks are defined as asynchronous if they need to call async methods. ### Correct Handling of Asynchronous Secrets Here’s how you can handle it: 1. Define Flow and Tasks as Asynchronous: Ensure that if you call an async method inside the flow or task, you use
async
and
await
. 2. Correct Code Example:
Copy code
python
from prefect import flow, get_run_logger
from prefect.blocks.system import Secret

@flow
async def my_flow():
    logger = get_run_logger()
    try:
        secret_block = await Secret.load("my-secret")
        secret_value = secret_block.value
        <http://logger.info|logger.info>(f"The secret value is: {secret_value}")
    except Exception as e:
        logger.error(f"Error retrieving secret: {e}")

my_flow()
### Using Await Inside Flows and Tasks - Main Changes: - Use
async def
for the flow definition. - Use
await
when calling the
Secret.load
method. ### Example in Detailed Steps: 1. Create a Secret Block (if not already created):
Copy code
python
    from prefect.blocks.system import Secret

    # Create and save a secret
    secret = Secret(value="my_secret_value")
    secret.save(name="my-secret")
2. Define and Run the Flow asynchronously:
Copy code
python
    from prefect import flow, get_run_logger
    from prefect.blocks.system import Secret

    @flow
    async def my_flow():
        logger = get_run_logger()
        try:
            # Await the loading of the secret block
            secret_block = await Secret.load("my-secret")
            secret_value = secret_block.value
            <http://logger.info|logger.info>(f"The secret value is: {secret_value}")
        except Exception as e:
            logger.error(f"Error retrieving secret: {e}")

    if __name__ == "__main__":
        import anyio
        anyio.run(my_flow)
3. Install Required Libraries (if
anyio
is not already installed):
Copy code
sh
    pip install anyio
By making the appropriate usage of
async
and
await
, you should be able to retrieve the secret without running into the
coroutine
object error. ### Summary: Ensure that you await the async methods when using Prefect's async APIs. In this case,
Secret.load
is asynchronous and therefore needs to be awaited. For more detailed guidance, refer to the documentation on managing secrets: - Prefect 3.0: Managing Secrets This should resolve the "coroutine object has no attribute 'value'" error and help you fetch your secrets seamlessly. Happy debugging!
m
@Marvin, how to best test my code locally? If I have main defined including deployment parameters, schedules etc. How can I test locally best?
m
Ah, the joys of testing locally. Ensuring that your flows, deployments, and schedules run smoothly locally before deploying them is crucial. Here are some best practices for testing your Prefect code locally: ### Best Practices for Local Testing 1. Use Prefect's Local Testing Capabilities: Prefect provides several utilities to help you run and test your flows locally. 2. Isolate Configuration and Execution: Keep your deployment configurations (like schedules, parameters) separate from your flow definitions. This makes it easier to run tests without triggering deployment logic. 3. Mock External Services: Use mocking frameworks to simulate interactions with external services. This can help you test your flows without relying on actual external systems. 4. Use Prefect CLI: Prefect CLI commands can be used to test different aspects of your flow and deployment locally. ### Example Structure Let's restructure your code for better local testing: #### 1. Flow Definition in a Separate Module
Copy code
python
# flows.py
from prefect import flow, get_run_logger

@flow
def my_flow(param1, param2):
    logger = get_run_logger()
    <http://logger.info|logger.info>(f"Running with param1={param1} and param2={param2}")
    return param1 + param2
#### 2. Deployment Configuration and Execution
Copy code
python
# deploy.py
from prefect.deployments import Deployment
from prefect.server.schemas.schedules import IntervalSchedule
from datetime import timedelta
from flows import my_flow

def create_deployment():
    schedule = IntervalSchedule(interval=timedelta(minutes=10))
    deployment = Deployment(
        flow=my_flow,
        name="my_flow_deployment",
        schedule=schedule,
        parameters={"param1": 1, "param2": 2},
        tags=["development"],
    )
    deployment.apply()

if __name__ == "__main__":
    create_deployment()
#### 3. Local Testing Script
Copy code
python
# test_flow.py
from flows import my_flow

def test_my_flow():
    result = my_flow(param1=1, param2=2)
    assert result == 3

if __name__ == "__main__":
    test_my_flow()
    print("All tests passed!")
### Local Testing Workflow 1. Run the Flow Directly: You can test your flow logic directly by running the flow without deploying it.
Copy code
sh
    python test_flow.py
2. Use Prefect CLI for More Comprehensive Tests: Utilize Prefect CLI commands to simulate deployments. This helps in testing deployment configuration and schedules:
Copy code
sh
    # Register and run
    prefect deployment build -n my_flow_deployment deploy.py:my_flow -p "param1=1 param2=2"
    prefect deployment apply my_flow-deployment.yaml
    prefect deployment run 'my_flow_deployment/my_flow'
3. Mock External Interactions: Use libraries like
unittest.mock
to mock interactions with external services.
Copy code
python
    # example_mock.py
    from unittest.mock import patch
    from flows import my_flow

    @patch("flows.some_external_service")
    def test_my_flow(mock_service):
        mock_service.return_value = "mocked_value"
        result = my_flow(param1=1, param2=2)
        assert result == 3

    if __name__ == "__main__":
        test_my_flow()
        print("All mocked tests passed!")
4. Running Deployment Configs Without Cloud: Prefect allows you to use local agents to simulate deployed environments.
Copy code
sh
    # Start a local agent
    prefect agent start -q 'default'
    # Apply and run the deployment locally
    prefect deployment run -n 'my_flow_deployment'
### Continuous Integration (CI) Integrate these tests into your CI pipeline to automatically run tests upon different triggers (e.g., pull requests, pushes to the
main
branch). ### Summary 1. Isolate Flow Logic: Keep your flow definitions and deployment configurations separate. 2. Run Local Tests: Directly test your flows' logic locally using standard Python testing methodologies.
3. Mock External Services: Use mocking to simulate external service interactions. 4. Prefect CLI: Use Prefect CLI to simulate deployments and flow runs. 5. Local Agents: Run local agents to mimic the cloud environment. By following these best practices, you will ensure that your flow and deployment configurations are robust and ready for production. Happy testing!
m
@Marvin, could you please help me troubleshoot my code for prefect 3. gcs_bucket.upload_from_path("notes.txt", "prefect.yaml") returns <coroutine object sync_compatible.<locals>.coroutine_wrapper.<locals>.ctx_call at 0x10cca1c60> what's going wrong