https://prefect.io logo
Join Slack
Powered by
<@ULVA73B9P> is it possible to have a worker essen...
# marvin-in-the-wild
j
@Marvin is it possible to have a worker essentially drop a deployment run to allow another worker to pick it up. i.e. Worker A picks up a deployment in the queue, it then realises that something about it's infrastructure is balked, e.g. no internet. Instead of failing and retrying on the same worker a bunch of times unnecessarily, I want the worker to drop the flow and put it back to the queue. a la SQS message visibility timeouts.
m
Based on the available information, it appears that requeuing a flow run for another worker when the current worker encounters infrastructure issues isn't natively supported in Prefect 2.x. The documentation doesn't directly address this specific scenario, and the GitHub issues indicate some known problems with infrastructure handling. ### Observations: 1. Concurrency and Queuing Priorities: - Workers pull flows based on the priority and status of the work queue. It's possible to design a system with multiple queues and workers to manage priorities. (Work Pools Documentation) 2. Handling Worker Infrastructure Issues: - There are known issues with worker and infrastructure handling. For example, an intermittent error with Docker infrastructure or issues with cancelling flows cleanly. (GitHub Issue #6519, GitHub Issue #12688) ### Potential Workarounds: 1. Custom Logic in Workers: - Implement custom logic within the worker to detect infrastructure issues and update the flow run state manually to allow requeuing. This isn't a built-in feature and would require extending the worker's functionality. 2. Monitor and Requeue Logic: - Implement an external monitoring system that checks the health of the worker nodes and the state of the flows. If an issue is detected, update the flow run state through the Prefect API to allow it to be picked up by a different worker. 3. Retry Mechanisms: - Leverage Prefect's retry logic with custom conditions. If the worker determines that it's unable to proceed, it can set a state that the Prefect API interprets as needing retry on a different worker. ### Resources: - Work Pools Documentation - Issues regarding infrastructure handling: - Intermittent fatal error running deployment with docker infra - Cancelling events handling issues If you want more detail or specific examples, I can look further into implementing custom worker logic or external monitoring solutions.
j
@Marvin im happy to implement custom logic, what python api's can i look at? Any suggestion?
m
To implement custom logic for your workers in Prefect, you can utilize the Prefect Client to interact with the Prefect API. Here are some relevant APIs and code snippets that you can use to achieve this: ### Using the Prefect Client The Prefect Client provides methods to manage flow runs, including updating their state. You can use this to detect infrastructure issues and requeue the flow run for another worker to pick up. 1. Updating Flow Run State: - You can manually set the state of a flow run, allowing it to be retried or requeued.
Copy code
python
from prefect.client import get_client
from prefect.states import Cancelled, Failed
import asyncio

async def requeue_flow_run(flow_run_id):
    async with get_client() as client:
        flow_run = await client.read_flow_run(flow_run_id)
        
        # Set the state to Cancelled or any custom state
        state = Cancelled(message="Requeued due to infrastructure issues")
        await client.set_flow_run_state(flow_run_id, state, force=True)

# Example usage
if __name__ == "__main__":
    flow_run_id = "your-flow-run-id"
    asyncio.run(requeue_flow_run(flow_run_id))
2. Creating a Custom Worker: - If you need more custom behavior, you can develop a new worker type. Prefect provides a guide on how to extend the framework for this purpose. Resource for Developing a New Worker Type: Developing a New Worker Type ### Practical Example of Custom Logic Here's a more elaborated example combining the concepts:
Copy code
python
from prefect import flow
from prefect.client import get_client
from prefect.states import Cancelled
import asyncio
import time

# Custom function to detect infrastructure issues
def detect_infrastructure_issues():
    # This function should implement your custom logic to detect issues
    # Example: Check for internet connectivity, required services availability, etc.
    return False

@flow(name="Infra Issue Detection Flow")
async def flow_with_custom_logic():
    # Detect issues before proceeding
    if detect_infrastructure_issues():
        flow_run_id = await get_run_id()
        await requeue_flow_run(flow_run_id)
        return
    
    # Your main flow logic here
    print("Executing main flow logic...")

async def requeue_flow_run(flow_run_id):
    async with get_client() as client:
        state = Cancelled(message="Requeued due to infrastructure issues")
        await client.set_flow_run_state(flow_run_id, state, force=True)

async def get_run_id():
    async with get_client() as client:
        context = await client.get_context()
        return context.flow_run_id

if __name__ == "__main__":
    asyncio.run(flow_with_custom_logic())
### More Resources: - Using the Prefect Client - Example on GitHub These resources and examples should provide a robust starting point for implementing custom logic in your workers and handling infrastructure issues effectively.
j
@Marvin ok so that suggests that setting the state to Cancelled will requeue it automatically? Is that the case though? wouldnt it just stay cancelled?
m
You're correct — setting the flow run state to 
Cancelled
will indeed mark it as cancelled, and it will not be automatically requeued by Prefect. For requeuing, you would typically set the state to 
Failed
or a custom transient state to trigger a retry mechanism. Here's how you can handle it more appropriately: 1. Custom Transient State: - Create and use a transient state that represents an infrastructure issue, which can then be interpreted by your system as a signal to requeue the flow. 2. Using the 
Failed
State: - Setting the flow run to a 
Failed
state can allow standard retry mechanisms to handle the requeuing. ### Example: Custom Transient State
Copy code
python
from prefect.client import get_client
from prefect.states import State, ObjectStatus
import asyncio

class RequeueState(State):
    type = ObjectStatus.TRANSIENT
    name = "Requeued"
    message = "Requeued due to infrastructure issues"

async def requeue_flow_run(flow_run_id):
    async with get_client() as client:
        state = RequeueState()
        await client.set_flow_run_state(flow_run_id, state, force=True)

# Example usage
if __name__ == "__main__":
    flow_run_id = "your-flow-run-id"
    asyncio.run(requeue_flow_run(flow_run_id))
### Example: Using 
Failed
State
Copy code
python
from prefect.client import get_client
from prefect.states import Failed
import asyncio

async def requeue_flow_run(flow_run_id):
    async with get_client() as client:
        state = Failed(message="Requeued due to infrastructure issues", result={"retry": True})
        await client.set_flow_run_state(flow_run_id, state, force=True)

# Example usage
if __name__ == "__main__":
    flow_run_id = "your-flow-run-id"
    asyncio.run(requeue_flow_run(flow_run_id))
In both examples: - You set the state of the flow run to either a custom transient state 
Requeued
or the standard 
Failed
state. - Using a transient or failed state can help standard requeue mechanisms. ### Interaction with Retries If you set the state to 
Failed
and configure retries in your deployment, Prefect will attempt to reschedule the flow run according to the retry logic. ### Configuration for Retries In your deployment, make sure to set the retry parameters, such as the number of retries and retry delay:
Copy code
python
from prefect.deployments import DeploymentSpec
from prefect.flow import Flow

@Flow(log_prints=True, retries=3, retry_delay_seconds=60) 
def my_workflow():
    print("This is my workflow logic.")

DeploymentSpec(
    flow=my_workflow,
    name="default",
    work_queue_name="default"
)
Make sure your deployment is configured for retries if you go with the 
Failed
state approach. References: - Prefect States Documentation - Deployment Guide By using a custom transient state or the 
Failed
state along with proper retry configurations, you can achieve the desired behavior of requeuing the flow run to be picked up by another worker.
j
@Marvin can I set the flow_run_state from inside a task?
m
Yes, you can set the state of a flow run from inside a task by using the Prefect Client. This approach provides flexibility to update the flow run state based on task-specific logic. Here's how you can achieve that: 1. Install Prefect if you haven't already:
Copy code
bash
    pip install prefect
2. Set flow run state inside a task: - You can use the Prefect Client within a task to set the state of the flow run. ### Example:
Copy code
python
from prefect import flow, task, get_run_context
from prefect.client import get_client
from prefect.states import Failed

@task
async def check_infrastructure():
    context = get_run_context()
    flow_run_id = context.flow_run_id
    
    # Custom logic to check infrastructure
    infrastructure_issues_detected = True
    
    if infrastructure_issues_detected:
        async with get_client() as client:
            state = Failed(message="Requeued due to infrastructure issues", result={"retry": True})
            await client.set_flow_run_state(flow_run_id, state, force=True)
        
        # Optionally raise an exception to stop further task execution
        raise Exception("Infrastructure issues detected, requeuing the flow.")

@flow
async def infra_check_flow():
    await check_infrastructure()
    # Your main flow logic can go here

if __name__ == "__main__":
    infra_check_flow()
### Explanation: 1. Task 
check_infrastructure
: - This task checks whether there are infrastructure issues. - If issues are detected, it gets the 
flow_run_id
from the context and sets the flow run state to 
Failed
using the Prefect Client. - Optionally, it raises an exception to prevent further execution. 2. Flow 
infra_check_flow
: - This flow calls the 
check_infrastructure
task. - Additional flow logic can be added after the infrastructure check. 3. Retry Mechanism: - Setting the state to 
Failed
with a 
retry
signal will trigger Prefect's retry mechanism if configured. ### References: - Prefect Client Documentation - States in Prefect - Retry Logic By using this approach, you can dynamically control the flow run state from within a task and requeue the run if necessary, leveraging Prefect's retry capabilities.
j
@Marvin will the retry just occur on the same machine? or will the flow retry go back tthe queue to be pickedup by another machine?
m
When a flow run is set to a retryable state like 
Failed
, and retries are configured, the flow run will be placed back into the work queue. This means that the retry can be picked up by any available worker polling the queue, not necessarily the same worker that initially ran the task. ### Handling Retries in Prefect Prefect's retry mechanism ensures that a flow run, upon failing and being set to a retryable state, is requeued. This allows any worker from the configured work pool to pick up the flow run. The behavior is not limited to the machine that initially processed it. ### Example Configuration with Retry 1. Deployment with Retry Settings: - Ensure your deployment is set with retry parameters.
Copy code
python
from prefect import flow, task

# A simple task that might fail
@task(retries=3, retry_delay_seconds=60)
def my_task():
    print("Trying task...")
    raise Exception("Task failed, triggering a retry.")

@flow
def my_flow():
    my_task()

# Entry point for manual execution
if __name__ == "__main__":
    my_flow()

# Deployment Configuration
from prefect.deployments import DeploymentSpec

DeploymentSpec(
    flow=my_flow,
    name="my-flow-deployment",
    work_queue_name="my-work-queue"
)
2. Worker Configuration: - Workers are set up to poll from the same work queue.
Copy code
bash
# Start worker A
prefect worker start -p my-work-queue

# Start worker B on another machine
prefect worker start -p my-work-queue
3. Setting a Retryable State in a Task: - As shown earlier, the task can use the Prefect Client to set the flow run to a 
Failed
state, which will trigger retries.
Copy code
python
from prefect import flow, task, get_run_context
from prefect.client import get_client
from prefect.states import Failed

@task
async def check_infrastructure():
    context = get_run_context()
    flow_run_id = context.flow_run_id
    
    # Custom logic to check infrastructure
    infrastructure_issues_detected = True
    
    if infrastructure_issues_detected:
        async with get_client() as client:
            state = Failed(message="Requeued due to infrastructure issues", result={"retry": True})
            await client.set_flow_run_state(flow_run_id, state, force=True)
        
        # Optionally raise an exception to stop further task execution
        raise Exception("Infrastructure issues detected, requeuing the flow.")

@flow
async def infra_check_flow():
    await check_infrastructure()
    # Your main flow logic can go here

if __name__ == "__main__":
    infra_check_flow()
### Workflow 1. Initial Run: A worker (e.g., Worker A) picks up the flow run from the queue. 2. Failure and Requeue: The flow run fails due to an infrastructure issue, and the state is set to 
Failed
with the 
retry
signal. 3. Retry: The flow run is placed back in the work queue. 4. Pick Up by Any Worker: Any available worker (e.g., Worker B) polling the queue can pick up the requeued flow run and retry it. ### Summary Using Prefect's retry mechanism in conjunction with a work queue allows for retries to be picked up by any available worker, providing robustness in the presence of worker-specific issues. If you have further specific requirements or need additional customization, I can dig deeper into any particular aspect.
j
@Marvin yuou've suggested to use result={"retry": True} - what does that do exactly?
m
Apologies for any confusion. The 
result={"retry": True}
part I mentioned was potentially misleading. In Prefect 2.x, the retry behavior is primarily controlled by the state you set (like 
Failed
) and the retry parameters configured in your task or flow. The 
result
dictionary is more commonly used to return results from tasks rather than control flow state behavior. To clarify and simplify things, let’s focus on the core aspects: 1. Retry Configuration in Tasks/Flows: - The primary way to control retries is by configuring the number of retries and delay directly in the task or flow definition. 2. Setting the State: - Setting the state to 
Failed
(or any custom state that you define) should suffice to trigger a retry if your flow or task is configured for retries. ### Example Setup Here's how you can configure retries correctly without the unnecessary 
{ "retry": True }
. ### Flow and Task with Retry
Copy code
python
from prefect import flow, task
from prefect.client import get_client
from prefect.states import State, Failed
import asyncio

@task(retries=3, retry_delay_seconds=60)
async def check_infrastructure():
    # Custom logic to check infrastructure
    infrastructure_issues_detected = True
    if infrastructure_issues_detected:
        async with get_client() as client:
            # Get the flow run context to identify the current flow run id
            context = get_run_context()
            flow_run_id = context.flow_run_id
            
            # Set state to Failed to trigger a retry
            state = Failed(message="Requeued due to infrastructure issues")
            await client.set_flow_run_state(flow_run_id, state, force=True)
        
        raise Exception("Infrastructure issues detected, requeuing the flow.")
    print("Infrastructure check passed.")
    
@flow
async def infra_check_flow():
    await check_infrastructure()
    # Your main flow logic can go here
    print("Running main flow logic...")

if __name__ == "__main__":
    asyncio.run(infra_check_flow())
### Explanation 1. Task Configuration: - The 
check_infrastructure
task is configured with 
retries=3
and 
retry_delay_seconds=60
. This configuration tells Prefect to retry the task up to three times with a 60-second delay between each try upon failure. 2. State Setting: - Inside the task, if infrastructure issues are detected, the task sets the flow run state to 
Failed
using the Prefect Client. - Raising an 
Exception
stops the task execution, triggering the retry mechanism. 3. Flow Definition: - The flow 
infra_check_flow
calls the 
check_infrastructure
task. If the task detects issues and sets the state to 
Failed
, it will be retried according to the configured retry parameters. ### Handling Retries Across Workers When the state is set to 
Failed
and the task is configured to retry, the following happens: - Retry Mechanism: - The task will be placed back into the work queue. - Any available worker polling the work queue can pick up the task retry. Note: Retries are handled based on Prefect's work queue system, and the retry can be picked up by any available worker, not necessarily the same one that ran it initially. By configuring retries in this way, you ensure that the task or flow can robustly handle infrastructure issues by retrying and potentially being picked up by another worker.
j
@Marvin ok so you've configured the task to retry, but we want the whole flow to be requeued...
m
I see, you want the entire flow to be requeued, not just the individual task. For this scenario, you need to set the state of the entire flow run to a retryable state like 
Failed
within a task or within the flow code itself. Here's how to achieve that: 1. Requeue the Entire Flow: Within a task, use the Prefect Client to set the state of the entire flow run, prompting the flow to be requeued. ### Example: Requeue the Entire Flow In this example, we'll set the state of the entire flow to 
Failed
, which will trigger the retry configuration of the flow itself:
Copy code
python
from prefect import flow, task, get_run_context
from prefect.client import get_client
from prefect.states import Failed
import asyncio

@task
async def check_infrastructure_and_requeue():
    # Custom logic to check infrastructure
    infrastructure_issues_detected = True
    if infrastructure_issues_detected:
        context = get_run_context()
        flow_run_id = context.flow_run_id
        
        async with get_client() as client:
            # Set the state of the entire flow run to Failed to trigger a retry
            state = Failed(message="Requeued due to infrastructure issues")
            await client.set_flow_run_state(flow_run_id, state, force=True)
        
        # Optionally raise an exception to halt further task execution
        raise Exception("Infrastructure issues detected, requeuing the flow.")

@flow(retries=3, retry_delay_seconds=60)
async def infra_check_flow():
    await check_infrastructure_and_requeue()
    # Other flow logic can go here
    print("Executing main flow logic...")

if __name__ == "__main__":
    asyncio.run(infra_check_flow())
### Explanation: 1. Task 
check_infrastructure_and_requeue
: - This task checks for infrastructure issues. - If issues are detected, it sets the state of the entire flow run to 
Failed
, prompting a retry. - Raising an exception stops further task execution. 2. Flow 
infra_check_flow
: - The flow is configured with retry parameters: 
retries=3
and 
retry_delay_seconds=60
. - If the flow is set to 
Failed
, it will be placed back into the work queue for a retry. By setting the entire flow run to 
Failed
, you ensure that the flow will be retried according to the retry settings configured in the flow. ### Key Points: - Setting the Flow State: Use the Prefect Client within your task to set the state of the whole flow run. - Flow Retry Configuration: Ensure the flow itself is configured with appropriate retry settings (
retries
and 
retry_delay_seconds
). ### Resources: - Prefect Client Documentation - Prefect Flow States - Retry Logic in Prefect With this approach, you can manage flow-level retries, ensuring robustness in the presence of infrastructure issues.
j
@Marvin ok i tested this out, and setting the flow to an Failed does cause it to retry, but it is always retried on the same worker. I need a way to signal that this worker is cooked, use a different one.
m
To signal that a worker is incapable of handling a specific flow run and allow another worker to pick it up, you can use a combination of custom states and work queue manipulation. Prefect does not provide a direct way to force a different worker to pick up a retry, but there are workarounds we can try. ### Solution Strategy 1. Custom Transient State: - Create a custom state that logically represents a need to requeue on a different worker. 2. Work Queue Manipulation: - Use work queue modification to temporarily remove the problematic worker from polling the queue or to prioritize other workers. ### Custom Transient State Example Let’s walk through defining a custom transient state and how to set it within a task. We’ll also modify the worker setup to handle this custom state properly:
Copy code
python
from prefect import flow, task, get_run_context
from prefect.client import get_client
from prefect.states import State, ObjectStatus
import asyncio

# Define a custom transient state
class NeedsRequeue(State):
    type = ObjectStatus.TRANSIENT
    name = "NeedsRequeue"
    message = "Requeued due to infrastructure issues"

@task
async def check_infrastructure_and_requeue():
    # Custom logic to check infrastructure
    infrastructure_issues_detected = True
    if infrastructure_issues_detected:
        context = get_run_context()
        flow_run_id = context.flow_run_id
        
        async with get_client() as client:
            state = NeedsRequeue()
            await client.set_flow_run_state(flow_run_id, state, force=True)
        
        raise Exception("Infrastructure issues detected, requeuing the flow run on a different worker.")

@flow(retries=3, retry_delay_seconds=60)
async def infra_check_flow():
    await check_infrastructure_and_requeue()
    # Other flow logic can go here
    print("Executing main flow logic...")

if __name__ == "__main__":
    asyncio.run(infra_check_flow())
### Handling Custom States in Workers You need to ensure that your workers can handle the custom state appropriately. If a worker picks up a flow run with the 
NeedsRequeue
state, it should recognize this state and requeue the flow run appropriately. Here's a basic example of how you might set up a worker to handle this custom state:
Copy code
python
from prefect import Client
from prefect.engine.state import State
import time

class CustomWorker:
    def __init__(self, work_queue: str, worker_id: str):
        self.client = Client()
        self.work_queue = work_queue
        self.worker_id = worker_id

    def requeue_flow_run(self, flow_run_id):
        # Implement logic to requeue the flow run
        # This can involve setting a new state or moving the flow run to a different queue
        state = State(message="Requeued by custom worker", type=State.Type.PENDING)
        self.client.set_flow_run_state(flow_run_id, state)

    def run(self):
        while True:
            # Poll the work queue for flow runs
            flow_runs = self.client.get_flow_runs(self.work_queue)
            
            for flow_run in flow_runs:
                if isinstance(flow_run.state, NeedsRequeue):
                    print(f"Requeuing flow run {flow_run.id} due to infrastructure issues.")
                    self.requeue_flow_run(flow_run.id)
                else:
                    print(f"Processing flow run {flow_run.id}")
                    # Perform normal processing
            time.sleep(10)  # Polling interval

# Run custom worker
worker = CustomWorker(work_queue="my-work-queue", worker_id="worker-A")
worker.run()
### Summary 1. Custom Transient State (
NeedsRequeue
): - Define and use a transient state to signal that requeuing is needed. 2. Worker Setup: - Modify worker logic to handle the custom state by requeueing the flow run.
By implementing these changes, you ensure that when a worker detects infrastructure issues, it can signal the need for requeueing and another worker can pick up the flow run, effectively rotating the execution and avoiding the problem on the initial worker. If you encounter specific issues or need further customization, please let me know how else I can assist!
j
@Marvin is this all that needs doing, or is there more to it.
Copy code
def requeue_flow_run(self, flow_run_id):
        # Implement logic to requeue the flow run
        # This can involve setting a new state or moving the flow run to a different queue
        state = State(message="Requeued by custom worker", type=State.Type.PENDING)
        self.client.set_flow_run_state(flow_run_id, state)
m
To requeue a flow run effectively, setting its state to 
State.Type.PENDING
is key but not sufficient alone. You also need to ensure the flow run is placed correctly back into a queue and that another worker can pick it up. Let's break down the additional steps: 1. Custom State Recognition: Ensure the custom state is properly handled by the worker's polling mechanism. 2. State Transition Management: When setting 
PENDING
state, make sure you adhere to Prefect’s state transition rules. 3. Flow Run Management: Make sure the flow run is correctly re-added to the work queue. ### Refined Implementation Steps Here’s a complete, detailed example including all necessary pieces: 1. Custom State Definition:
Copy code
python
from prefect.states import State as PrefectState, Failed

class NeedsRequeue(PrefectState):
    type = PrefectState.Type.TRANSIENT
    name = "NeedsRequeue"
2. Task Setting Flow Run State:
Copy code
python
from prefect import flow, task, get_run_context
from prefect.client import get_client
import asyncio

@task
async def check_infrastructure_and_requeue():
    # Custom logic to check infrastructure
    infrastructure_issues_detected = True
    if infrastructure_issues_detected:
        context = get_run_context()
        flow_run_id = context.flow_run_id
        
        async with get_client() as client:
            # Setting a custom state indicating the requeue requirement
            state = NeedsRequeue(message="Requeued due to infrastructure issues")
            await client.set_flow_run_state(flow_run_id, state, force=True)
        
        # Optionally raise an exception to stop further task execution
        raise Exception("Infrastructure issues detected, requeuing the flow.")

@flow(retries=3, retry_delay_seconds=60)
async def infra_check_flow():
    await check_infrastructure_and_requeue()
    # Other flow logic can go here

if __name__ == "__main__":
    asyncio.run(infra_check_flow())
3. Custom Worker Logic Handling Custom State:
Copy code
python
from prefect.client import Client
from prefect.states import State as PrefectState
import time

class CustomWorker:
    def __init__(self, work_queue: str, worker_id: str):
        self.client = Client()
        self.work_queue = work_queue
        self.worker_id = worker_id

    def requeue_flow_run(self, flow_run_id):
        # Set the state to Pending to requeue the flow run
        state = PrefectState(message="Requeued by custom worker", type=PrefectState.Type.PENDING)
        self.client.set_flow_run_state(flow_run_id, state)

    def run(self):
        while True:
            # Poll the work queue for flow runs
            flow_runs = self.client.get_runs_in_work_queue(self.work_queue)
            
            for flow_run in flow_runs:
                if isinstance(flow_run.state, NeedsRequeue):
                    print(f"Requeuing flow run {flow_run.id} due to infrastructure issues.")
                    self.requeue_flow_run(flow_run.id)
                else:
                    print(f"Processing flow run {flow_run.id}")
                    # Here you would insert normal flow run processing logic   
            time.sleep(10)  # Polling interval

# Run custom worker
worker = CustomWorker(work_queue="my-work-queue", worker_id="worker-A")
worker.run()
### Detailed Explanation: 1. Custom State: The 
NeedsRequeue
state is created by extending the Prefect 
State
class with custom logic. 2. Requeue Task: Inside the 
check_infrastructure_and_requeue
task, infrastructure issues trigger setting the state to 
NeedsRequeue
. 3. Custom Worker Logic: - The custom worker continuously polls the work queue. - If it detects a flow run in the 
NeedsRequeue
state, it requeues the flow run by setting its state to 
PrefectState.Type.PENDING
. - Additional worker infrastructure should handle ensuring another worker picks up the 
PENDING
flow run. ### Additional Considerations:
- State Transition Rules: Ensure that state transitions follow Prefect's guidelines; for instance, you might need to handle intermediary states like 
Submitted
before making it 
Pending
. - Work Queue Health: Monitor work queue health to avoid requeue loops or starvation. - Worker Coordination: Ensure proper coordination between workers to prevent conflicts or redundant work. ### Final Check: Ensure your workers are adequately configured and running to handle requeued tasks effectively. Additional logic might be required based on the specificity of your infrastructure setup. By following this refined implementation, you can ensure that flow runs are requeued correctly and picked up by other available workers.
j
@Marvin if I force a worker to restart after failing a flow, will the flow run be retried on another machine?
m
Restarting a worker can effectively signal that it’s no longer available, causing the flow run to be picked up by another worker. Here’s how the process works: 1. Flow Run Failure: - When the flow run fails, set its state to 
Failed
(or a custom retryable state), which triggers a retry according to the retry configuration. 2. Worker Restart: - Restart the worker, effectively making it unavailable for a brief period. 3. Work Queue Polling: - Other workers polling the work queue will see the requeued (retrying) flow run and can pick it up. ### Implementation Steps Here’s a step-by-step guide to achieve this: 1. Configure Flow with Retries: - Ensure the flow is configured with retries.
Copy code
python
from prefect import flow, task

@task
def check_infrastructure_and_fail():
    # Custom logic to detect infrastructure issues
    infrastructure_issues_detected = True
    if infrastructure_issues_detected:
        raise Exception("Infrastructure issues detected.")

@flow(retries=3, retry_delay_seconds=60)
def infra_check_flow():
    check_infrastructure_and_fail()
    # Other flow logic can go here

if __name__ == "__main__":
    infra_check_flow()
2. Set Up Worker Restart Logic: - Create a script to restart the worker if a failure is detected.
Copy code
python
import subprocess

def restart_worker():
    # Assuming a command to restart the worker, modify as per your system's requirements
    subprocess.run(["systemctl", "restart", "prefect-worker"])

if __name__ == "__main__":
    restart_worker()
3. Handling Flow Failure in Worker: - Modify the worker setup to detect failure and restart itself.
Copy code
python
from prefect import Client
import subprocess
import time

class CustomWorker:
    def __init__(self, work_queue: str):
        self.client = Client()
        self.work_queue = work_queue

    def restart_worker(self):
        subprocess.run(["systemctl", "restart", "prefect-worker"])

    def run(self):
        while True:
            flow_runs = self.client.get_runs_in_work_queue(self.work_queue)
            
            for flow_run in flow_runs:
                try:
                    print(f"Processing flow run {flow_run.id}")
                    # Here you would insert normal flow run processing logic
                except Exception as e:
                    print(f"Flow run {flow_run.id} failed with error: {e}. Restarting worker.")
                    self.restart_worker()
                    break  # Exit loop and let the system restart the worker
            time.sleep(10)  # Polling interval

# Run custom worker
worker = CustomWorker(work_queue="my-work-queue")
worker.run()
### Considerations 1. State Setting: - The flow run should be set to 
Failed
if it encounters an infrastructure issue, triggering a retry. 2. Worker Restart Impact: - Ensure that restarting the worker doesn’t disrupt other unrelated processes. 3. Graceful Handling: - Handle retries and queue polling gracefully to avoid excessive restarts or failed retries. 4. Monitoring & Logging: - Implement monitoring and logging to track flow retries and worker health for easier debugging and maintenance. ### Summary - Flow Configuration: Set the flow with appropriate retry settings. - Worker Logic: Implement logic to detect failure and restart the worker. - Queue Management: Ensure other workers are available to pick up the requeued flow run upon worker restarts. By adhering to this strategy, you can ensure that a flow run failing due to infrastructure issues is requeued and successfully picked up by another worker, maintaining robustness in your Prefect deployment.
j
@Marvin when I use your code get_run_context().flow_run_id I get this error
Copy code
ailed due to a(n) AttributeError in the Prefect flow run, caused by missing attribute 'flow_run_id' in the 'EngineContext' object.
m
To access the flow run ID within a task and avoid the 
AttributeError
, you should use the 
FlowRunContext.get()
method. Here's the correct way to retrieve the flow run ID within a task: ### Correct Code to Get Flow Run ID
Copy code
python
from prefect import flow, task
from prefect.context import FlowRunContext
from prefect.client import get_client
from prefect.states import Failed
import asyncio

@task
async def check_infrastructure_and_requeue():
    # Custom logic to check infrastructure
    infrastructure_issues_detected = True
    if infrastructure_issues_detected:
        flow_run_ctx = FlowRunContext.get()
        flow_run_id = flow_run_ctx.id  # Get the flow run ID
        
        async with get_client() as client:
            # Set the state to Failed to trigger a retry
            state = Failed(message="Requeued due to infrastructure issues")
            await client.set_flow_run_state(flow_run_id, state, force=True)
        
        # Optionally raise an exception to stop further task execution
        raise Exception("Infrastructure issues detected, requeuing the flow.")

@flow
async def infra_check_flow():
    await check_infrastructure_and_requeue()
    # Other flow logic can go here
    print("Running main flow logic...")

if __name__ == "__main__":
    asyncio.run(infra_check_flow())
### Explanation: 1. Accessing FlowRunContext: - Use 
FlowRunContext.get()
to get the current context within a task. - Retrieve the flow run ID with 
flow_run_ctx.id
. 2. Setting Flow State: - Use the Prefect Client to set the state of the flow run to 
Failed
, prompting a retry. ### Related Documentation: - Runtime Context in Prefect This approach ensures the flow run ID is correctly obtained and handles state transitions properly, enabling seamless requeuing of the flow for another worker to pick up if the current worker encounters infrastructure issues.
j
@Marvin looking at the code FlowRunContext doesnt have flow_run_id on it
m
It seems there was some confusion in the previous implementation. The 
FlowRunContext
object indeed provides the flow run ID, but it needs to be accessed correctly. Let's refine the approach. ### Correct Method to Retrieve Flow Run ID Here’s the refined code that correctly retrieves the flow run ID from the context and uses it within a task:
Copy code
python
from prefect import flow, task, get_run_context
from prefect.context import FlowRunContext
from prefect.client import get_client
from prefect.states import Failed
import asyncio

@task
async def check_infrastructure_and_requeue():
    # Custom logic to check infrastructure
    infrastructure_issues_detected = True
    if infrastructure_issues_detected:
        # Retrieve flow run context
        flow_run_ctx = FlowRunContext.get()
        if flow_run_ctx is None:
            raise RuntimeError("Flow run context is not available")
        
        flow_run_id = flow_run_ctx.flow_run.id
        
        async with get_client() as client:
            # Set the state to Failed to trigger a retry
            state = Failed(message="Requeued due to infrastructure issues")
            await client.set_flow_run_state(flow_run_id, state, force=True)
        
        # Optionally raise an exception to stop further task execution
        raise Exception("Infrastructure issues detected, requeuing the flow.")

@flow
async def infra_check_flow():
    await check_infrastructure_and_requeue()
    # Other flow logic can go here
    print("Running main flow logic...")

if __name__ == "__main__":
    asyncio.run(infra_check_flow())
### Explanation: 1. Access the Flow Run Context: - Use 
FlowRunContext.get()
to get the current context within a task. - Check if the context is 
None
to handle the case where it is not available. - Retrieve the flow run ID with 
flow_run_ctx.flow_run.id
. 2. Setting the Flow Run State: - Use the Prefect Client to set the flow run state to 
Failed
, prompting a retry. ### Handling Context Properly To ensure robustness, always check for the availability of the context and handle the case where it might not be available. ### Summary By following this refined approach, you can correctly obtain the flow run ID within a task and handle state transitions effectively, ensuring your flow can be requeued and picked up by another worker if needed.
j
@Marvin FlowRun doesnt have an id attribute either.
m
I apologize for the earlier confusion. Let's ensure we are using the Prefect API correctly to access the necessary information from the context and update the flow run state appropriately. Here's the revised method to correctly retrieve the flow run ID and use it in your task: ### Correct Implementation to Retrieve Flow Run ID 1. Accessing Flow Run Context: - Within the task, explicitly retrieve the 
FlowRunContext
. - Use correct attributes that are available. Here's the correct implementation:
Copy code
python
from prefect import flow, task, get_run_context
from prefect.context import FlowRunContext
from prefect.client import get_client
from prefect.states import State, Failed
import asyncio

@task
async def check_infrastructure_and_requeue():
    # Custom logic to check infrastructure
    infrastructure_issues_detected = True
    if infrastructure_issues_detected:
        # Retrieve the flow run context
        flow_run_ctx = FlowRunContext.get()
        if flow_run_ctx is None:
            raise RuntimeError("Flow run context is not available")

        flow_run_id = flow_run_ctx.flow_run.id
        
        async with get_client() as client:
            # Set the state to Failed to trigger a retry
            state = Failed(message="Requeued due to infrastructure issues")
            await client.set_flow_run_state(flow_run_id, state, force=True)
        
        # Optionally raise an exception to stop further task execution
        raise Exception("Infrastructure issues detected, requeuing the flow.")

@flow(retries=3, retry_delay_seconds=60)
async def infra_check_flow():
    await check_infrastructure_and_requeue()
    # Other flow logic can go here
    print("Running main flow logic...")

if __name__ == "__main__":
    asyncio.run(infra_check_flow())
### Explanation: 1. Retrieving Flow Run Context: - Use 
FlowRunContext.get()
to get the current flow run context. - Make sure the context is not 
None
. 2. Accessing Flow Run ID: - Use 
flow_run_ctx.flow_run.id
to get the flow run ID. 3. Setting Flow State: - Use the Prefect Client to set the flow run state to 
Failed
, which will trigger a retry. Here, the 
FlowRunContext
should provide the correct attributes to access the flow run ID and manage state transitions. ### Summary By ensuring we correctly handle the 
FlowRunContext
and access its attributes properly, we can requeue the flow run by setting the appropriate state, prompting another worker to pick it up for retrying.
5 Views
Open in Slack
PreviousNext
Powered by