<@ULVA73B9P> Hi, I'm trying to deploy a bunch of f...
# ask-marvin
s
@Marvin Hi, I'm trying to deploy a bunch of flows on my ECS Fargate Cluster (using Prefect Cloud) and I'm trying to understand how to organize my deployments when I have multiple flows. Let's say that they're all going to run on the same ECS worker pool – am I supposed to have one docker image in my build section that will contain all my flows? Am I supposed to have multiple Docker images instead? I was wondering about the same thing about the S3 storage layer – am I supposed to push the source to different folders for the different flows even if they're all in the same folder / repo? In general I'm trying to understand what the worker Docker image is used for – when would one make a custom image? Right now I'm pushing my code to S3 and pulling it again from S3 during my flow runs but 1. I have to add a
prefect.deployments.steps.pip_install_requirements
to the pull section in order to have the dependencies installed (as they weren't installed for some reason) 2. What do I even need the docker image for? I was under the impression that this image would be pulled / used for making the flow runs but it doesn't seem like it I've read this page https://docs.prefect.io/latest/guides/prefect-deploy/ many times and It's quite overwhelming 😅
m
Here's how you can approach your deployment with Prefect and AWS ECS Fargate with Prefect Cloud: ### Organizing Deployments - The custom Docker image used should contain all the dependencies necessary to run your flows but not necessarily the flow code itself. - You can build a single Docker image with all the dependencies required by your multiple flows if the dependencies are largely shared and manage the flow code separately. ### Docker Images - The purpose of the Docker image is to provide an execution environment with all the necessary dependencies for your flows. - Typically, Docker images for Prefect are built with the necessary Python environment and system libraries required for flow execution, and Prefect itself. - A custom Docker image is useful when your flows require specific systems libraries, versioned dependencies, or a specific operating system configuration that isn't available in standard images. ### Source Code and S3 Storage - When using S3 storage, you can push your flow's source code to different folders for organizational purposes; however, it's not strictly necessary, especially if the flows share the same repository. - If using S3, the individual flow scripts or serialized flow objects are stored there, and the worker Docker image can pull these for execution. ### Flow Dependencies - If you're finding it necessary to install dependencies at runtime with
prefect.deployments.steps.pip_install_requirements
, it suggests they aren't included in your Docker image which should ideally contain all the dependencies. - Ensure that your Docker image includes a RUN command that installs all the necessary requirements at build time, for example:
Copy code
dockerfile
  COPY requirements.txt /tmp/
  RUN pip install -r /tmp/requirements.txt
### Why Docker? - The Docker image is crucial for ensuring a consistent, reproducible environment across all flow runs, regardless of where it's being deployed. - By using Docker, you can avoid the "it works on my machine" problem, ensuring your flows run as expected in production. ### Issues and Solutions: 1. If dependencies are not installed, it indicates that the Docker image build process didn't include these dependencies. Verify your Dockerfile to ensure it includes all required dependencies. 2. The Docker image is indeed used to execute the flow; however, if it seems like dependencies are missing, the image may need to be updated to include them. ### Documentation and GitHub Issues - Unfortunately, the excerpts from the documentation and the no issues found on GitHub query do not provide a step-by-step guide for your exact scenario, emphasizing the need for considering the points above when crafting your deployment strategy. Additionally, ensure that your CI/CD pipeline is configured properly to handle code changes and manage deployments across your different flows and environments. To summarize, use a Docker image with all necessary dependencies included, manage flow source code on S3, and make versions clear. Adjustments might be required to ensure that the Docker image fully meets the needs of your Prefect flows.
s
@Marvin You said this:
- When using S3 storage, you can push your flow's source code to different folders for organizational purposes; however, it's not strictly necessary, especially if the flows share the same repository.
- If using S3, the individual flow scripts or serialized flow objects are stored there, and the worker Docker image can pull these for execution.
1. I had to add the S3 steps because otherwise I was getting an error regarding "/opt/prefect/data" not existing when my flow runs. 2. How do I specify that my flow runs should use a specific docker image?
m
Managing flow runs with a specific Docker image and addressing the error with
/opt/prefect/data
can be done as follows: ### Specifying Specific Docker Image for Flow Runs: To specify that your flow runs should use a specific Docker image, you need to configure your flow's infrastructure to refer to the image you've created. This is done by setting up your deployment with the
Docker
infrastructure type, where you can specify the image name. In a deployment YAML file, it would look something like this:
Copy code
yaml
# Your deployment configuration
name: MyFlowDeployment
flow_location: /path/to/flow.py
infrastructure:
  type: Docker
  image: my-custom-image:latest
  ...
When creating a deployment via the Prefect API or UI, ensure that the Docker image you want to use is specified in the infrastructure settings. ### Resolving the
/opt/prefect/data
Error: The error regarding
/opt/prefect/data
not existing could be happening if your Docker image doesn't have that directory created, or if the running user does not have proper permissions to access it. You can resolve this by ensuring the Docker image creates that directory and assigns appropriate permissions in your
Dockerfile
. Here's an example snippet:
Copy code
dockerfile
RUN mkdir -p /opt/prefect/data && chown -R prefect /opt/prefect/data
Make sure that the user
prefect
exists in the container or use the appropriate user that the flows run as. ### Github Issue: The GitHub issue [Intermittent fatal error running deployment with docker infra (https://github.com/PrefectHQ/prefect/issues/6519)] seems to be related to an intermittent problem with Docker deployments that crash with a docker error. This might not be directly related to your questions but is good to be aware of when running Prefect with Docker deployments. Make sure to test these configurations across different environments and ensure that they work consistently. Additionally, always set the Prefect API URL appropriately so that your Docker containers can communicate with Prefect Cloud if you're running in a containerized environment.
s
the first part is pure hallucination lol
never seen
flow_location
as a key